HC Deb 23 March 1911 vol 23 cc603-4
Mr. KERR-SMILEY

asked whether the Prime Minister's attention has been directed to a speech made by the Home Secretary on the 14th inst., in which he said on several occasions statements had been made from the Bench reflecting on trade unions in language which was extremely ignorant and out of touch with modern thought, and which had greatly complicated the administration of justice; whether the Home Secretary expressed the opinion of the Government on this occasion; and whether, having regard to the nature of the charge made against judges, who have no opportunity of defending themselves, he will provide Members with an opportunity of discussing it in this House?

The PRIME MINISTER

I understand that my right hon. Friend was replying as a Minister in the ordinary way to a deputation, and it is obvious that he did not, in the observation referred to, purport to be speaking for the Government. The answer to the third part of the question is in the negative.

Earl WINTERTON

Having regard to the general accusation made against the learned judges, will the right hon. Gentleman reconsider his decision, after Easter, to give a day?

The PRIME MINISTER

Perhaps the Noble Lord will put the question afterwards.

Mr. O'GRADY

May I ask the right hon. Gentleman whether, apart from the question of opinion, the Home Secretary was merely making a statement of fact?

The PRIME MINISTER

I would not like to say; that is a matter of opinion.

Mr. O'GRADY

I can give instances in my own case.