HC Deb 13 February 1911 vol 21 cc690-1
Mr. DENMAN

asked whether, having regard to the fact that a large number of Members of this House and leading civil servants spend little time in hunting or shooting but on the other hand appreciate a summer holiday, His Majesty's Government will either themselves consider the question of making the normal Session begin in the autumn and end in May or June, or appoint a Select Committee to consider it?

The PRIME MINISTER

All the arguments, on the one side and the other, are so well-known to the House that I do not think that any useful purpose would be served by the appointment of a Committee such as my honourable Friend suggests. His proposal appears to me to possess many attractions, but until there are greater hopes of the House unanimously approving it than exist at present the Government is not in a position to take any action. It is a matter which can only be determined by general consent.

Lord HUGH CECIL

Would it not be possible to take the King's Speech before Christmas and then begin the Session late in January without the King's Speech delaying business?

Mr. AUSTEN CHAMBERLAIN

Could the right hon. Gentleman afford the House an opportunity of expressing its opinion?

Mr. JAMES HOPE

Could the right hon. hon. Gentleman guarantee that the Session would in fact end in May or June even if it began in the autumn?

The PRIME MINISTER

The hon. Member has put his finger on the real difficulty. My anticipation is that when we get to the end of June we should be told there was this question and that and another week and another week.

Mr. DENMAN

Is not Whitsuntide as well-known a festival in the calendar as August 12th?

The PRIME MINISTER

It is well known it is much more movable.