HC Deb 16 August 1911 vol 29 c1912
Captain CLIVE

asked the Attorney General whether his attention has been, called to an infringement of the Corrupt and Illegal Practices Act, 1883, during the Middleton by-election, when favours were distributed from the door of the Liberal committee room to the crowd in the street; and what action he proposes to take in the matter?

Sir RUFUS ISAACS

The only evidence in my possession is that of a reproduction of a photograph which appeared in the "Manchester Guardian," to which my attention was called by the hon. Member. It is said to be a bad picture, and does not afford sufficient evidence of an offence under the Corrupt Practices Act. I know nothing further of it, but I am making inquiries into the matter to see if there is any other evidence.

Captain CLIVE

Does the right hon. Gentleman suggest that the photograph to which his attention has been called can be otherwise than accurate?

Sir RUFUS ISAACS

The photograph which I saw, depicted a small crowd of children holding up their hands, and a man at the door of the committee room holding up his hands. That is not, in my opinion, sufficient evidence.