HC Deb 15 March 1910 vol 15 cc170-1
Mr. DOUGLAS HALL

asked what was the total reduction in strength of the garrisons manning the forts in the Isle of Wight in February, 1910, as compared with the strength of the garrisons in February, 1906; whether he would give the reason for reducing the strength of these garrisons, in view of the strategical importance of the Isle of Wight; whether the reserve of ammunition and stores in these forts had been reduced, and, if so, for what reason; and whether reports had reached the War Office to the effect that the reserve of ammunition and stores in these forts was below the standard usually maintained?

Mr. HALDANE

It has been frequently explained in this House that it is highly inexpedient to publish details of this nature connected with our national defences, and I hope the hon. Member will understand that I am not treating him exceptionally in expressing my regret that I am unable to furnish him with the information required. Changes in armaments were carried out on the recommendations of General Owen's Committee. As regards the last part of the question, I may add that no such reports have been received.

Mr. DOUGLAS HALL

asked the Secretary for War whether his attention. had been called to the difficulty and expense of training the Regular and Territorial troops in the Isle of Wight in musketry owing to the want of a proper rifle range; whether a safe and suitable site had been reported on by a military board; and, if so, whether he would take the necessary steps to provide for the acquisition of that or some other suitable spot?

Mr. HALDANE

My attention has been drawn to this matter. A suitable site has been reported on by a military board. Steps will be taken for securing a site with all possible despatch.