HC Deb 07 July 1910 vol 18 c1780
Sir FREDERICK BANBURY (for Lord Charles Beresford)

asked if there was a Committee on the question of the rank and status of the engineer officers of His Majesty's Fleet; and, if so, whether he can now state to the House the finding of that Committee?

Mr. McKENNA

I must refer the Noble and Gallant Lord to the reply given to a similar question from him on 30th March last.

Sir F. BANBURY

May I ask whether the interval between the 3rd of March last and now has not been sufficiently long to-enable the right hon. Gentleman to reply?

Mr. McKENNA

No, Sir, the Committee to which the Noble Lord referred sat some years ago. Its proceedings were confidential, and remain confidential to-the present time.

Sir F. BANBURY

Does that mean that the proceedings will not be published?

Mr. McKENNA

Yes, Sir, they will not be published.

Sir F. BANBURY

Why did the right hon. Gentleman not say so before?

Mr. McKENNA

I did say so before.