HC Deb 26 February 1897 vol 46 cc1260-1
MR. BRYN ROBERTS

I beg to ask the Under Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether, in or about November 1895, one of the Great Powers of Europe made a proposal to Great Britain, in conjunction with, the other Great Powers, to enter the Dardanelles and to seize the Sultan; if so, what reply did Her Majesty's Government make to the proposal?

*MR. CURZON

No such proposal was made to Her Majesty's Government.

MR. BRYCE

DO I understand the right hon. Gentleman to say that the statement in the Question, which is taken from the speech of M. Hanotaux, is in fact incorrect?

*MR. CURZON

No, Sir, I have been asked here whether a proposal has been made to Her Majesty's Government, and that is the question I have answered I do not understand that M. Hanotaux said anything about a proposal to Her Majesty's Government.

MR. BRYCE

Perhaps it would be beter to put another question to clear the matter up.

MR. BRYN ROBERTS

Was not part of the proposal made to Her Majesty's Government to enter the Dardanelles?

*MR. CURZON

I cannot bisect the proposal. No proposal of the kind was made to Her Majesty's Government. ["Hear, hear!"]

MR. BRYN ROBERTS

The right hon. Gentleman's answer is ambiguous. ["Oh, oh!"] He says he cannot bisect the proposal, but at the same time says that no such proposal was made I wish to ask him whether a proposal to enter the Dardanelles by force was made to Her Majesty's Government?

*MR. CURZON

I have nothing to add to the answer I have already given. [Ministerial cheers.]

MR. BRYN ROBERTS

intimated that he should repeat the Question.