HC Deb 09 December 1878 vol 243 cc300-1
LORD ELCHO

asked, Whether Her Majesty's Government entertain any doubt as to the trustworthiness of the Rhodope Report; and, whether they have taken, or are about to take, any steps to carry into effect the objects for which the Rhodope European Commission was appointed?

THE CHANCELLOR OF THE EXCHEQUER

Sir, perhaps, as the Question of the hon. and learned Gentleman (Mr. Serjeant Simon) on this subject was addressed to me, and it was at my request he postponed it, I may be allowed to answer my noble Friend. It is not quite correct to speak of "the Rhodope Report." No single united Report has been made by the members of that Commission. Four members have addressed separate and identic Reports to their own Ambassadors; and in these circumstances it would not be possible to take any political action upon it without serious consideration. With regard, however, to the recommendations contained in the Report as to the sufferings which undoubtedly have been brought to light, it is difficult to see how any adequate relief can be provided, either by private charity or by the funds of the Turkish Government. Her Majesty's Government are considering whether they can make any proposal on this subject.

LORD ELCHO

May I point out that my Question referred also to the trustworthiness of the Report, and that I should like to know whether any doubt is entertained on the subject?

THE CHANCELLOR OF THE EXCHEQUER

Sir, my noble Friend will see that is a Question very difficult to answer one way or the other. The Report which has been addressed to Her Majesty's Government by Her Majesty's Ambassador is one of considerable importance, and it undoubtedly discloses a serious state of suffering, for which it would be really desirable that some remedy could be found; but I can hardly answer the noble Lord's Question.

LORD ELCHO

gave Notice that he should repeat the Question.

MR. SERJEANT SIMON

said, in consequence of the Answer which had just been given, he begged to ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Whether, in the circumstance that the Report was not a united Report of the Commission, it was in contemplation to take steps to verify the Report of our Commissioners, or whether the Report would be allowed to drop?

THE CHANCELLOR OF THE EXCHEQUER

I think it would be better that that Question should be put after due Notice has been given.

MR. SERJEANT SIMON

gave Notice that he should put the Question tomorrow.