HC Deb 28 February 1845 vol 78 cc137-8
Mr. E. B. Roche

said, that he had a question to ask of the hon. and learned Member for Bath, for the purpose of asking which he had come expressly from Ireland. As this was a question referring to a matter in which he felt that his character as a Member of that House, and as a gentleman, was concerned, he trusted he was not asking too much of the House in begging to be allowed to make a few preliminary remarks by way of explanation of the grounds on which he asked it. A very short time since, he saw with considerable astonishment a speech attributed to the hon. Gentleman in the Times newspaper.

Mr. Speaker

said, that the hon. Member was irregular in referring to a newspaper for what was said in that House in a previous debate.

Mr. Roche

Well, then, I heard of a speech which has been attributed to the hon. and learned Gentleman, in which I find the following words, in alluding to a large body of the Irish Members:—"They have run away from their posts."

Mr. Speaker

It is quite evident, from the hon. Gentleman's observations, that he is referring to a speech made by the hon. and learned Member for Bath in a former debate; and I must inform the hon. Member that it is quite irregular for any hon. Gentlemen to allude to a previous debate.

Mr. Roche

I may be permitted at any rate to ask this question. Certain observations, I understand, were made—supposing that they were made—

Mr. Speaker

said, he was sure the House would feel that it was quite impossible that the hon. Member could be allowed to refer to any words spoken by another hon. Member in a previous debate.

The question was then put, that the Order of the Day for the Committee of Ways and Means be read.

Back to