§ Mr. MaplesTo ask the Prime Minister if he will list the occasions since 1 May 1997 on which a Minister in the Cabinet Office has used(a) an aircraft belonging to the RAF and (b) a privately chartered aircraft together with (i) details of the take-off and destination points, (ii) ground waiting time, (iii) dates of departure and return, (iv) purpose of the trip, (v) cost of the trip to the Cabinet Office and (vi) details of people accompanying the Minister, indicating the total costs of all such travel borne by the Cabinet Office (1) since 1 May 1997 and (2) between 1 May 1996 and 1 May 1997. [55548]
§ The Prime Minister[holding answer 19 October 1998]: Ministers are required under the terms of the Ministerial Code always to make efficient and cost-effective travel arrangements. The rules on travel for Ministers are the same as those that applied under the previous Administration. The volume of travel by RAF
743Waircraft and private charter flights reflects our Presidency of the European Union, our chairmanship of the G8, and the leading role played by this Government in peace talks in Northern Ireland and the Middle East. This Question
744W
Date Destination Purpose Numbers accompnying minister May 1997 Northern Ireland Official visit 6 8 The Hague Informal European Council 20 22 Paris NATO/Russia Summit 11 12 June 1997 Malmo—Bonn Bilaterals in Bonn 20 17 18 Paris Talks and dinner with President Chirac 14 12 Amsterdam European Council 41 39 Denver—New York G7 Summit and UN General Assembly 58 63 Hong Kong Handover ceremony to China 21 23 July 1997 Madrid NATO Summit 32 16 August 1997 Bologna Bilateral with Italian PM/Holiday 12 2 Pisa—Toulouse Bilateral with French PM/Holiday 3 13 5 September 1997 Scotland Regional tour/Balmoral 6 10 Wrexham Regional tour 10 11 October 1997 Moscow Talks with Presidentn Yeltsin 31 Luxembourg—Strasbourg Dinner with Prime Minister Juncker Council of Europe Summit 12 11 Belfast Talks in Stormont and regional tour 9 11 Edinburgh CHOGM 16 18 November 1997 Luxembourg EU Jobs Summit 17 14 Bosnia Visting troops/Bosnian Leaders 21 22 December 1997 Luxembourg European Council 28 36 Belfast Official visit 8 10 January 1998 Japan EU/Japan Summit 50 51 The Hague Speech to the Ridderzaal 8 9 February 1998 Washington Talks with Clinton 54 55 March 1998 Glasgow—Dundee—Teesside Regional tour 11 10 Bonn Bilateral visit 7 Paris Address National Assembly and bilateral meeting 13 April 1998 Belfast Northern Ireland Peace Agreement 8 Belfast Northern Ireland Peace Agreement 5 14 Spain Bilateral visit and holiday 6 Cairo—Jeddah—Amman—Israel Middle East Tour 46 48 47 51 53 Manchester Regional Tour 7 9 could be answered in the precise terms requested only at disproportionate cost. Between 2 May 1997 and 30 September 1998 I have used RAF aircraft/private charter aircraft on the following occasions:
745W
Date Destination Purpose Numbers accompanying minister May 1998 Amsterdam—Brussels Speech in The Hague and Special EMU Council in Brussels 11 12 16 Belfast Regional tour and talks 8 8 Belfast Talks 13 7 Geneva Speech to WTO 10 Belfast Talks 8 9 June 1998 Madrid—Dublin—Belfast Pre-European Council tour 11 11 6 6 The Hague Pre-European Council tour 7 10 Rome—Vienna Pre-European Council tour 9 10 9 Stockholm—Helsinki— Pre-European Council tour 12 Copenhagen— Brussels—Luxembourg—Bonn— Paris 13 13 13 Strasbourg Speech to European Parliament 14 14 Teesside Regional tour 6 Frankfurt Inauguration of European Central Bank 10 12 July 1998 Belfast Talks 10 9 Edinburgh Regional tour 11 Teesside Regional tour 16 4 August 1998 Bologna Bilateral with Italian PM/Holiday 10 1 Florence—Toulouse Bilateral with French PM/Holiday 3 14 5 Toulouse—Belfast—Toulouse Talks in Northern Ireland 3 3 Toulouse—London—Belfast Talks in Northern Ireland 2 15 9 8 Glasgow—Aberdeen Regional tour 7 7 September 1998 Belfast Talks 10 9 Blackpool—Teesside—Newcastle—Lyneham Regional tour 7 6 6 Lyneham—Highgrove Dinner at Highgrove 4 The average cost of the flights undertaken for these trips for the 17 months between May 1997 and September 1998 is £11,613 compared to £11,136 under the last year of the previous Administration. In addition to these flights, the then Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster used an RAF plane to make an official visit to Yeovilton in July 1997 accompanied by 3 officials. The cost was £1,109.