COASTAL ZONE PROTECTION: MANAGEMENT (Hansard, 15 July 1994)

§ The Earl of Arran

In October 1993, the Department of the Environment and the Welsh Office published two discussion papers on coastal issues:Managing the Coast and Development Below Low Water Mark. Both papers were prepared with the full co-operation of all relevant departments. They fulfilled the commitments made by the Government in its response (Cm 2011: July 1992) to the report from the Environment Select Committee (April 1992) on coastal zone protection and planning.

Extensive comments were received on the two papers and reflected a wide range of views. Arrangements are being made for those comments and a summary of them to be made available in the Department of the Environment's Library.

118WA

We recognise the heightened importance attached to effective management of the coastal zone, and to ensuring that a balance is achieved between the commercial, environmental, leisure and other demands; —for example, military needs—on such areas, in accordance with the principles of sustainable development.

Following full consideration, we remain confident that existing statutory systems—including the specialised sectoral controls which apply offshore—are the most effective means of regulating development in the coastal zone. Accordingly, in recognition of the distinct needs of land and marine environments, we believe that a case has not been made for any general extension below low water mark of the jurisdiction of town find country planning legislation. However, we shall keep under continuing review the scope for making appropriate improvements to present arrangements: for example to ensure maximum transparency and liaison in the decision-making process. We shall also consider further the scope for addressing some more detailed points raised in responses to the recent consultation exercise.

However we accept there is concern in some quarters that new means of taking an overview of the impact and development of policies towards the coast are required, and that increased emphasis should be placed on the wider management of the coastal zone on the basis of defined goals and objectives.

We have already taken a number of initiatives to improve the planning and management of the coast: for example, publication of Planning Policy Guidance Note 20 on Coastal Planning; the launch last Autumn of a Strategy for Flood and Coastal Defence in England and Wales, recent proposals for a revised regime for the dredging of marine aggregates, and, more broadly, the continuing role of the Inter-Departmental Group on Coastal Policy, which provides a vehicle for effective liaison on coastal zone matters within central Government.

We have also laid before Parliament regulations to implement the provisions of the EC Habitats Directive, which include a new approach to the conservation of certain internationally important marine areas, and have supported the work of the nature conservation agencies in promoting the drawing up of management plans in a number of important estuaries.

We now propose to take further measures to enhance the effective co-ordination of policies for the coastal zone in England. Responding to the call for clear and comprehensive objectives, we intend to publish within a year a statement of national policy guidelines for the coast. This will draw together in a convenient form policy guidance already provided on coastal issues. In turn, public and private bodies, agencies and organisations will be asked to have due regard to the principles set out in the proposed guidelines, when giving consideration to actions which may impinge directly, or indirectly, on the coastal zone.

119WA

Secondly, reflecting the priority which we attach to informed discussion on coastal issues, we intend to create by the end of this year a standing forum on coastal zone management. It will have a broad and balanced membership, including central and local government, and commercial, conservation and recreation interests. We will consult on its membership and terms of reference. Such a forum should be an effective vehicle for promoting understanding of the national guidelines and building on liaison arrangements at regional and local level already established. It will complement, but not overlap with, existing Ministerial meetings dealing with specific issues such as flood and coastal defence.

Thirdly, in recognition of the growing role and coverage of coastal zone management plans, we believe there is a strong case for highlighting good practice and clarifying, where necessary, the interaction of the different elements of such management. The proposed forum will have an important role here in ensuring effective co-operation between the responsible bodies. We shall therefore set this work in hand, and, in addition, consider how best to monitor the management plans being developed locally.

Lastly, we shall proceed with the proposed review of bye-law powers relating to coastal management, and broaden its scope to look more widely at the general issue of implementing coastal zone management and the relationship between the voluntary principle and regulatory support. We shall therefore establish an inter-departmental working party to consider these matters, and in undertaking its task the group will consult widely with interested parties.

Colleagues in the Scottish Office are currently preparing a discussion paper on coastal policy which will reflect Scotland's distinctive circumstances. It is expected that this paper will be published in the Autumn. Colleagues in Northern Ireland also hope to issue a consultation paper on coastal policy to interested parties later in the year taking into account the different local government framework which exists. The Secretary of State for Wales will consider the position in Wales.

Linked with existing initiatives and measures, we believe that these proposals offer a sound basis for achieving increased responsiveness to the specific needs of the coastal zone, and will make a major contribution to helping reconcile conflicting pressures on this vital and potentially vulnerable resource.