§ Gillian MerronTo ask the Secretary of State for Defence what the latest figures are for deaths of(a) Gulf veterans and (b) among the control group; and if he will make a statement. [72883]
§ Dr. MoonieThe latest data, as al 30 June 2002, are shown in Table 1. Because of concern among some Gulf veterans over deaths caused by cancer, Table 2 provides a detailed breakdown of deaths from cancer (malignant neoplasm) by anatomical site.
Table 1: Deaths to UK Gulf veterans1 1 April 1991–30 June 2002—Causes2 ICD Chapter/Cause of death Gulf Era Mortality rate ratio3 All deaths 551 547 1.00 All cause coded deaths 542 537 1.00 I-XVI—Disease-related causes 213 256 0.83 I—Infectious and parasitic diseases 4 2 1.99 II—Cancers 92 99 0.93 III—Endocrine and immune disorders 1 4 0.25 V—Mental disorders 11 12 0.91 VI—Diseases of the nervous system and sense organs 10 8 1.24 VII—Diseases of the circulatory system 71 99 0.71 VIII—Diseases of the respiratory system 10 5 1.99 IX—Diseases of the digestive system 12 17 0.70 IV, X-XVI—All other disease-related causes 2 10 0.20 EXVII—External causes of injury and poisoning 329 281 1.17 Railway accidents 4 1 3.98 Motor vehicle accidents 118 92 1.27 Water transport accidents 4 1 3.98 Air and space accidents 25 18 1.38 Other vehicle accidents 0 2 0.00 Accidental poisoning 11 14 0.78 Accidental falls 8 7 1.14 Accidents due to fire/flames 0 2 0.00 Accidents due to natural environmental factors 2 2 1.00 Accidents due to submersion/suffocation/foreign bodies 17 7 2.42 Other accidents 31 28 1.14 Late effects of accident/injury 0 2 0.00 Suicide and injury undetermined whether accidental 100 97 1.03 Homicide 6 4 1.49 Injury resulting from the operations of war 3 4 0.75 Other deaths for which coded cause data are not yet available 5 4 — Overseas deaths for which cause data are not available 4 6 — 1Service and ex-service personnel only. 2 (Coded to ICD-9). World Health Organisation's International Classification of Diseases 9th revision 1977. 3Mortality rate ratios differ marginally from the crude deaths ratio owing to some small differences between the Gulf and Era cohorts. 910W
Table 2: Deaths due to neoplasms among UK Gulf veterans1 1 April 1991–30 June 2002—Major anatomical sites2 ICD 9 Site Gulf Era 140–239 All neoplasms 92 99 140–149 Malignant neoplasm of lip, oral cavity and pharynx 3 4 150–159 Malignant neoplasm of digestive organs and peritoneum 18 23 160–165 Malignant neoplasm of respiratory and intrathoracic organs 15 21 170–175 Malignant neoplasm of bone, connective tissue, skin and breast 14 8 We are currently discussing with the university of Manchester proposals for a detailed comparative study of the incidence of cancers among Gulf veterans and the Era comparison group and underlying factors, and hope to place a contract shortly. We also plan to commission a study of a cohort of Bosnia veterans on whom data are already available.
We are also discussing with the university of Manchester a detailed study of the factors underlying the figures for road traffic accident deaths, and hope to place a contract in the near future.
In addition, we have asked the Medical Research Council (MRC) to undertake an independent review of the research work that has been carried out into Gulf veterans' illnesses and advise on appropriate areas for future research. The MRC's conclusions will be published.
911W
Table 2: Deaths due to neoplasms among UK Gulf veterans1 1 April 1991–30 June 2002—Major anatomical sites2 ICD 9 Site Gulf Era 179–189 Malignant neoplasm of genitourinary organs 2 4 190–199 Malignant neoplasm of other and unspecified site 18 26 200–208 Malignant neoplasm of lymphatic and haematopoietic tissue 19 11 239 Unspecified nature 3 2 1Service and ex-service personnel only. 2Coded to ICD-9. World Health Organisation's International Classification of Diseases 9th revision 1977.