HL Deb 29 October 1952 vol 178 cc1068-80

3.3 p.m.

Order of the Day for the consideration of Commons Amendments read.

THE LORD CHANCELLOR (LORD SIMONDS)

My Lords, I beg to move that the Commons Amendments be now considered. There are a substantial number of Amendments which have been made to this Bill in the Commons. On behalf of Her Majesty's Government, I am prepared to accept all the Amendments which were made. I do not know whether it would be in accordance with your Lordships' wishes that I should take them en bloc, giving to your Lordships the opportunity, of course, to raise any point in regard to any particular Amendment, or whether you would wish me to go through the Amendments one by one, putting the question upon each Amendment. I can tell your Lordships this: the Amendments make no substantial alteration to the principle of the Bill, and in many respects I think they improve it. In particular, they carry out some suggestions that I made when I was introducing this Bill to your Lordships, and in other respects I think they go some way to satisfy the demands that were made, both in this House and in the other place, to secure additional safeguards for the liberty of the subject. I do not know whether I might venture to ask the noble and learned Earl, Lord Jowitt, whether he would wish me to take one course or the other for the convenience of the House.

Moved, That the Commons Amendments be now considered.—(The Lord Chancellor.)

EARL JOWITT

My Lords, so far as I am concerned, since I am asked, I feel that it would be better if the Lord Chancellor put the various clauses separately. I will say why I take that view. I think that some of these Amendments are exceedingly difficult to understand. So far as I am concerned, I have read and re-read them, and I do not know what they do at all. If I am in that position, it is possible that some other members of the House are in the same position. I feel that it would be useful to have some sort of explanation from the Lord Chancellor as we deal with the various clauses.

On Question, Motion agreed to.

    c1069
  1. COMMONS AMENDMENT 91 words
  2. c1070
  3. COMMONS AMENDMENT 257 words
  4. cc1070-1
  5. COMMONS AMENDMENT 289 words
  6. cc1071-2
  7. COMMONS AMENDMENTS 509 words
  8. c1072
  9. COMMONS AMENDMENTS 73 words
  10. cc1073-5
  11. COMMONS AMENDMENT 1,184 words
  12. cc1075-6
  13. COMMONS AMENDMENT 136 words
  14. c1076
  15. COMMONS AMENDMENT 62 words
  16. cc1076-9
  17. COMMONS AMENDMENTS 1,488 words
  18. cc1079-80
  19. COMMONS AMENDMENTS 102 words
  20. c1080
  21. COMMONS AMENDMENTS 151 words