HC Deb 23 February 1922 vol 150 cc2084-5
39. Colonel NEWMAN

asked the Prime Minister whether it is the intention of the Government, as set out in the Schedule to the Treaty Agreement Bill, that the relations between this country and the Irish Free State and the constitution and powers of the Free State shall be modelled on those of the Dominion Government of Canada as laid down in the Canada Act, 1867; and, if so, will provisions appear in the constitution recognising His Majesty as Commander-in-Chief of the Free State Military, Naval, and Air Forces, and providing for the enactments of the Government being printed in Erse and English, and Debates in the Houses of Legislature being carried on in either language?

Mr. CHURCHILL

In reply to the first part of the question I can only refer the hon. Member to Article 2 of the Treaty, which appears to me to be free from ambiguity. In reply to the second part, the form of the constitution is at present under consideration: the proper time to discuss its terms will be when it has been published and is brought before the House.

Colonel NEWMAN

Why was Article 2 put in the Treaty; and why was Canada mentioned?

Mr. CHURCHILL

It was mentioned because the Free State Constitution, in all respects in which Article 2 applies, will be governed by the same considerations as those which rule in regard to the Dominion of Canada.

Colonel NEWMAN

Will the King be Commander-in-Chief of the Irish Army?

Mr. CHURCHILL

I do not propose to add anything to the very clear account which I gave to the House. The House will see all these matters when the Constitution has been prepared.

Sir J. BUTCHER

When the Constitution is prepared, will this House be entitled to modify it? May I have an answer?

Mr. SPEAKER

That question does not arise from the question which appears on the Paper.