HC Deb 16 November 1920 vol 134 cc1706-7
66. Mr. CAIRNS

asked the Minister of Pensions if he is aware that two certificates were put in for Sapper William Heppel, No. 285,435, Royal Engineers, one from Dr. Newsted, M.D., Blyth, pointing out that Sapper Heppel was free from tuberculosis before he joined up, and one from Dr. Eaton, M.B.C.M., that tuber culosis had developed during military service; and will he pay the widow and child of this soldier a pension under such circumstances?

Major TRYON

The medical evidence to which my hon. Friend refers was very carefully considered in connection with the widow's claim to pension; but the medical advisers of the Ministry were of opinion that the disease from which this soldier died commenced after discharge, and was not due to service. Mrs. Heppel has been informed that, should she desire to appeal against the consequent refusal of pension, her local committee will assist her in preparing her case for the tribunal.

Mr. CAIRNS

Is the hon. and gallant Gentleman aware that this man never lost a day during his apprenticeship, nor before he joined the Army, at his work?

Major TRYON

We shall be very happy to help the widow to put that evidence before the independent tribunal.

Mr. CAIRNS

I have his employer's certificate here.