HC Deb 12 May 1948 vol 450 cc2102-3
16. Lady Grant

asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Civil Aviation whether he will direct B.E.A.C. to run a feeder air service with small aircraft daily between Edinburgh and Aberdeen to connect with the existing daily return service from Edinburgh to London.

Mr. Lindgren

No, Sir.

Lady Grant

Why not?

Mr. Lindgren

Because the service which has been withdrawn was not patronised and was uneconomic.

Lady Grant

Although we are all aware that the service did not pay for Dakotas, nevertheless, the suggestion is that small aircraft should be used as feeder aircraft between Aberdeen and Edinburgh. Cannot the Minister, therefore, reconsider the matter very carefully?

Mr. Lindgren

The only alternative is the D.H. 89, and I am informed that it would be equally uneconomic.

Mr. Hector Hughes

Is my hon. Friend aware that business people in the North of Scotland require a direct service between Aberdeen and London, and will he take steps to restore it?

Mr. Lindgren

They had the opportunity of showing their enthusiasm for a period of six months, and did not take it.

Mr. Lennox-Boyd

May I ask whether there was a service before nationalisation, and, in any case, will the Minister allow a private company to operate this much-needed service?

Mr. Lindgren

There was no prewar service. The question of operation by a private company is a matter for arrangement and negotiation with the Corporation under the appropriate Section of the Civil Aviation Act.

Mr. J. S. C. Reid

Does it come to this —that, as B.E.A.C. are unable to ran their services economically, and those who can are not allowed to do so, the result is that Scotland has to suffer?

Mr. Lindgren

It does not mean that at all. It does mean that where there is an alternative means of surface transport which is an effective competitor with air transport, the opportunities of profit are limited.

Mr. Speaker

The original Question was whether there was to be a feeder air service, but we are now getting very wide of the mark.