HC Deb 02 December 1947 vol 445 cc176-7
16. Mr. Michael Astor

asked the Secretary of State for War whether in the advertisement for recruiting for five years in the new Regular Army, under the caption, "George—you're kidding," he will have deleted the two sentences which imply official Government approval to the contention that a skilled worker cannot compete in industry today without a union card.

Mr. Shinwell

This section of the advertisement was intended merely to bring out the fact that, as announced by my predecessor on 17th June in reply to a Question by my hon. Friend the Member for Reading (Mr. Mikardo), the recognised soldier tradesman is not debarred from the advantage of trade union membership in civil life. I am, however, having the text revised so as to remove any mistaken impression which might be created by the present wording.

Mr. Astor

While I will wait to see what the revision will be, can the Minister assure the House that this caption, "George—you're kidding," is not a veiled reference to the Minister of Labour?

Mr. E. P. Smith

On a point of Order. Is it not a fact that no quotations are allowed in Questions? If so, could you, Sir, give your Ruling whether in future quotations might be allowed?

Mr. Speaker

I did not get the point. Would the hon. Member make it again?

Mr. E. P. Smith

There is a quotation in Question No. 16—"George—you're kidding."

Mr. Speaker

As the Question has passed the Table, I am sure that it is in Order.