§ 47. Mr. Granvilleasked the Prime Minister whether he is satisfied that the existing machinery for combating the U-boat menace ensures the most effective cooperation between the Allied Forces engaged in this task; and whether he will consider the suggestion made by Field Marshal Smuts for the setting up of an Allied General Staff to supervise anti-U-boat warfare?
§ The Prime MinisterThe answer to the first part of the Question is in the affirmative and to the second part in the negative.
§ Mr. GranvilleIs it not a fact that General Smuts' proposal was for an Allied anti-U-boat Staff, and would not this mean closer co-operation with the Allied Forces, and would not closer cooperation kill more U-boats and save more lives?
§ The Prime MinisterI have nothing to add to the answer I have given.
§ Mr. Clement DaviesHow often does this Committee over which the right hon. 1033 Gentleman presides meet, and is it not a fact that the preceding Committee, set up by the right hon. Gentleman, met only 18 times in 21 months?
§ The Prime MinisterIt meets weekly, or more often if there is occasion.
§ Mr. GranvilleIs it the intention to suggest the setting-up of an Allied General Staff for this purpose, as against a General Staff in this country?
§ The Prime MinisterThat is fully covered by my answer to the second part of the Question.
§ Mr. ShinwellWill my right hon. Friend consider asking the Committee to consult more frequently with officers of the Merchant Navy, who, no doubt, would be able to offer some suggestions as to practical methods of dealing with U-boats?
§ The Prime MinisterAll that aspect is fully borne in mind.