HC Deb 02 April 1935 vol 300 cc180-1
42. Mr. LEONARD

asked the Minister of Agriculture whether he is aware of the representations made by the Canadian High Commissioner and interested parties in Glasgow, asking for a re-examination of 44 Holstein breeding cows, 23 of which were condemned to slaughter a few hours after importation following a very severe voyage, solely on their conformation; that these cows were favourably reported on after examination by an experienced veterinary surgeon and the Glasgow Veterinary College as to health, had passed the tuberculin test of the Canadian Government, and been accepted as suitable breeding stock by four representative dairy farmers; and whether he can state why the request for a re-examination was not granted?

The MINISTER of AGRICULTURE (Mr. Elliot)

I am aware of the circumstances referred to in the question, but I would point out that the animals were not rejected for veterinary reasons. I did not order a re-examination, because I was satisfied that the original examination was carefully carried out and that the decision that these animals were unsuitable for breeding purposes was well-founded.

Mr. LEONARD

Is the right hon. Gentleman aware that a number of these cows have calved, and that the calves have been deemed to be healthy and of good quality? In view of the fact that they represent a large percentage of the shipment, does he not consider that in the circumstances it is only fair that there should be a re-examination, in support of which there is very weighty evidence?

Mr. ELLIOT

No, Sir. I cannot undertake to have any re-examination of these cattle.

Mr. LEONARD

Is it not a fact that there has been no test to confirm this opinion and that it lies at the discretion of one man?

Mr. ELLIOT

I am afraid that that is why it is so difficult to have a re-examination. One must rely upon one's authorised officer. As the hon. Member has said, it is a matter of opinion, and we have to take the opinion of the expert.

Mr. LEONARD

Is it not the case that the type of the calves is sufficient to justify reconsideration of the matter?

Mr. ELLIOT

No, Sir, I am afraid not.