HC Deb 04 February 1932 vol 261 cc238-9
31. Mr. ALBERY

asked the Minister of Health what steps have been taken to prevent differentiation in the rates of relief paid in areas where similar conditions prevail?

Sir H. YOUNG

The amount of relief to be afforded is for the decision of the public assistance authority in the light of the ascertained needs of the individual case. I have no power either to require uniformity or to define what, for the purpose of assessing relief, are similar conditions. As regards the area to which my hon. Friend called my attention in an earlier question, I am informed that the local authority have taken action to remove the difficulty to which he referred.

Mr. ALBERY

Has the right hon. Gentleman considered giving the public assistance committees information as to the amount that is being paid in other areas in similar cases in order to get some kind of co-ordination?

Sir H. YOUNG

Yes. All measures will be taken in order to see that public assistance committees have useful information of that kind.

Mr. McGOVERN

In view of the fact that there is a great difference in the scales, in the case of many large areas, will the right hon. Gentleman consider the advisability of convening a conference in order to get rid of these differences?

Sir H. YOUNG

I doubt very much whether such a conference would be useful. The hon. Member knows that local variations are due to local conditions.

Mr. KIRKWOOD

Could not the Minister of Health issue a circular intimating a standard scale of relief just as is done in the ease of unemployment insurance?

Sir H. YOUNG

If the hon. Member will consider my answer to the question, he will see that I have no power to prescribe any scale of payment.