HC Deb 23 April 1931 vol 251 cc1154-5
64. Mr. C. WILLIAMS

asked the Secretary for Mines whether the Government will consider the introduction of legislation with a view to nationalising royalties in this country?

Mr. SHINWELL

I am afraid that there is no possibility of such legislation at present.

Mr. WILLIAMS

On a point of Order. May I ask for your guidance on this matter, Mr. Speaker? This question was originally addressed to the Prime Minister, because it affects the time of the House. It was changed, with notice to me, but without asking in any other way for my opinion. How are we to find out on the Floor of this House about matters concerning legislation, if when we put questions to the Prime Minister they are transferred to a Department?

Mr. SPEAKER

It is not my business to decide who answers questions.

Mr. WILLIAMS

Has not a private Member the right of direct access to the Prime Minister for the purpose of putting questions dealing with legislation?

Mr. SPEAKER

Questions are answered by the Minister who happens to be responsible for the subject to which the question refers.

Mr. WILLIAMS

If I had asked a question as to when legislation is coming on I should have been referred to the Prime Minister. It is quite impossible for us to get information, if all matters which may be connected with a Department are transferred to it.