HC Deb 07 December 1922 vol 159 cc1989-90
68. Lieut.-Colonel Sir EDWARD GRIGG

asked the Prime Minister whether there is any record of the letter alleged to have been addressed to Lord Curzon by the late M. Gounaris on 19th February, 1922, regarding the condition of the Greek army in Asia Minor and of Lord Curzon's reply; whether the records, if any, substantiate the version of this correspondence published in the Press; and whether the records show that this correspondence was communicated to Lord Curzon's colleagues and considered by the Cabinet?

The PRIME MINISTER

The hon. and gallant Member is doubtless referring to the note from M. Gounaris of 15th February, which was communicated to the Cabinet, as well as the reply returned to it. Some extracts from M. Gounaris' note have been correctly reproduced in the Press.

Mr. ASQUITH

Will the right hon. Gentleman not consider the expediency and the necessity of laying before the House, papers with regard to the whole of these events in the East, which are necessary to form any just conclusion?

The PRIME MINISTER

I agree with the right hon. Gentleman that to lay particular papers would be useless, but before making any such promise I should have some idea as to the scope and period during which he wishes that papers should be laid.

Mr. LLOYD GEORGE

With regard to the question on the Paper, do I understand the right hon. Gentleman to say he has made inquiries as to whether that document was circulated to the Cabinet and that there is a record of it?

The PRIME MINISTER

I can say quite definitely that I sent the question to the proper source and got the reply that it was circulated to the Cabinet.

Lieut.-Commander KENWORTHY

When will there be an opportunity of discussing the Greek and Turkish question—the events leading up to the disaster that brought an end to the Coalition?

Mr. A. CHAMBERLAIN

Is there any record of the circulation of this document to the late Cabinet either in the Cabinet Secretariat or in the Foreign Office, and, if so, in which?

The PRIME MINISTER

It was from the Foreign Office that I got it, but I shall ask the Cabinet Secretariat to make sure.

Mr. CHAMBERLAIN

Some of us are very much surprised to hear that any such document was circulated, though our memory may be at fault.

The PRIME MINISTER

I should like to say I do not think there can be any possible mistake, because the records of the Foreign Office are that it was circulated.

Back to