HC Deb 01 February 1837 vol 36 cc58-60

The Sessional Order having been proposed,

Mr. Ewart

rose to bring forward the motion of which he had given notice, relative to the Admission of Strangers. The only reason that he knew of, why a Member's Order was requisite, for the admission of persons into the strangers' gallery, was, that it was supposed to be some guarantee for the respectability of the individuals admitted. Now he (Mr. Ewart) believed that a Member granted an order at the request of any individual, especially if that individual was one of his constituents. It was, therefore, in fact no guarantee at all; because the character or avocation of the individual seeking the order for admission was never inquired into. Another reason in justification of this impediment was said to be, that on all important occasions the gallery would be inconveniently crowded. Now, he did not think that a good argument, seeing that the same objection would apply to the present system; for there were six hundred and fifty-eight Members of that House, and it was very well known that the gallery would not contain more than two hundred individuals. Besides, if it became crowded, the officers would have directions to prevent the inconvenience, and Members at present were as much besieged on their way to the House as the doors of the gallery would then be. At present the modest and retiring man was sure to be excluded, while the forward and presuming was certain to succeed. The best proof of a person's anxiety to hear the debates was found in the fact of his coming early, and, on the system he proposed such a person would gain admission. It was well known that Members never refused a request made to them for an order, particularly if the applicant happened to be one of their constituents. He thought the present system a great injury to the unrepresented classes. He would suppose the case of a man who had no Member to represent him; why, such a man had no means of obtaining admission to the gallery of that House. For all the reasons he had mentioned—on account of the impediments to the public, and the inconvenience to Members—he should propose that the public should be admitted to the strangers' gallery of that House without a Member's Order; but that it should continue to be cleared, as at present, on the motion of a Member, and during divisions.

Lord John Russell

said, that notwithstanding the arguments of the hon. Gentleman, he still doubted the prudence of dispensing with a Member's Order, which, in his opinion, afforded some guarantee for the respectability of the person admitted. There were, in his opinion, great objections to the proposition of the hon. Member for Liverpool, as on all great occasions the gallery would be crowded to excess, and among the respectable individuals there might be many pickpockets. He had all along considered that admission by means of fees was objectionable, and for that reason he had enrolled himself among those who were in favour of its abolition. But, until some better ground than that stated by the hon. Member for Liverpool was brought forward, he thought things ought to remain as they now were.

Mr. Ewart

wished to know how the noble Lord, by the present system, would prevent pickpockets from entering the gallery of the House. It was notorious that Members gave their orders to any person that asked them, even to some of the porters in the streets.

Mr. Potter

suggested, that the gallery should be open until seven o'clock for the admission of persons having Members' orders, and that after that hour it should be open to the public in the way the hon. Member wished.

The House divided on Mr. Ewart's motion. Ayes 11; Noes 172: Majority 161.

List of the AYES.
Bowring, Dr. Roebuck, J. A.
Brotherton, J. Wason, R.
Gillon, W. D. Wilks, John
Hindley, C. Williams, W.
Lushington, Charles TELLERS.
Pechell, Capt. R. Ewart, W.
Potter, R. Wakley, T.
List of the NOES.
Alsager, Captain Gisborne, T.
Angerstein, John Goodricke, Sir F,
Arbuthnot, hon. H. Gordon, hon. W.
Archdall, M. Goring, Harry Dent
Ashley, Lord Goulburn, Sergeant
Baillie, H. D. Graham, Sir J.
Baring, F. Green, Thomas
Baring, W. B. Grey, Sir G. Bart.
Barnard, E. G. Halford, H.
Barry, G. S. Halse, James
Belfast, Lord Hanmer, Sir J., Bart.
Bell, Matthew Hardy, J.
Beresford, Sir J. Hawes, B.
Bish, T. P. Hay, Sir A. L.
Blackstone, W. S. Hector, C. J.
Bodkin, J. Henniker, Lord
Bonham, R. Francis Herbert, hon. Sidney
Borthwick, Peter Hodgson, J.
Brabazon, Sir W. Holland, Edward
Brady, Denis C. Hoy, J. B.
Browne, R. D. Ingham, R.
Bruen, F. Inglis, Sir R. H., Bart.
Buller, Sir J. B. Yarde Irton, Samuel
Butler, hon. Pierce James, W.
Campbell, Sir H. Jackson, Sergeant
Campbell, Sir. J. Jephson, C. D. O.
Canning, hon. C. Jervis, John
Chaplin, Colonel Jones, Wilson
Chichester, J. P. B. King, Edward B.
Clerk, Sir G. Lefevre, Charles S.
Clive, Edward Bolton Lennox, Lord G.
Clive, hon. R. H. Lennox, Lord A.
Colborne, N. W. R. Loch, James
Compton, H. C. Long, Walter
Conolly, E. M. Lushington, Dr.
Conyngham, Lord A. Mackinnon, W. A.
Dalbiac, Sir C. Maclean, D.
Dick, Quintin Macleod, R.
Donkin, Sir R. Macnamara, Major
Dugdale, W. S. Mactaggart, J.
Duncombe, T. Maher, John
Eastnor, Viscount Mahon, Lord
Eaton, Richard J. Mangles, J.
Egerton, Wm. Tatton Marshall, William
Ellice, E. Marsland, Thomas
Fancourt, Major Maule, hon. F.
Fector, John Minet Milton, Viscount
Fergusson, R. C. Molesworth, Sir W.
Finn, Wm. Francis Mordaunt, Sir J., Bart.
Fitzsimon, Chris. Morpeth, Lord
Follett, Sir W. Webb Murray, J. A.
Forbes, Wm. Nicholl, Dr.
Forester, hon. G. C. W. Norreys, Lord
Fremantle, Sir T. W. North, Frederick
French, F. O'Brien, W. S.
O'Connell, D. Strutt, E.
O'Connell, J. Stuart, V.
O'Connell, M. J. Talfourd, Segeant
O'Conor Don Tancred, H. W.
Ferrall, M. Thompson, Paul B.
Oliphant, Lawrence Tooke, W.
Palmer, Robert Tracey, C. H.
Parker, John Troubridge, Sir T.
Parrot, Jasper Tulk, C. A.
Pease, J. Twiss, H.
Peel, Sir R., Bart. Tynte, C. J. Kemeys
Peel, Col. J. Tyrrell, Sir J.
Peel, rt. hon. W. Y. Vesey, hon. T.
Pigot, Robert Villiers, C. P.
Pinney, W. Vyvyan, Sir R. R.
Plumptre, J. P. Walker, C. A.
Pollock, Sir Fred. Walter, John
Poulter, J. S. Warburton, H.
Powell, Colonel Ward, H. G.
Power, J. Weyland, Major
Price, S. G. Whitmore, Thomas C.
Pringle, A. Wilbraham, G.
Pryme, George Wilmot, Sir J. E.
Rice, rt. hon. T. S. Wodehouse, E.
Rolfe, Sir R. M. Wrightson, W.
Ross, Charles Wrottesley, Sir J., Bart.
Russell, Lord John Wyndham, Wadham
Sanford, E. A. Wynn, rt. hon. C. W.
Scott, Sir E. D. Young, G. F.
Scott, J. W.
Sibthorp, Colonel TELLERS.
Stanley, Edward Philips, G. R.
Stanley, Lord Steuart, R,
Back to