HC Deb 11 March 2004 vol 418 cc1708-9W
Mr. Nigel Jones

To ask the Deputy Prime Minister how many cases have been referred to the Adjudication Panel by the Standards Board for England in each month since its establishment; how many have been determined; how many have yet to be determined; how many of the cases relate wholly to a failure of a member of a parish council to complete the council's Register of Member Interests; if he will list the complaints made in the remaining cases; and what the decision of the Adjudication Panel w as in the determined cases. [160044]

Mr. Raynsford

A total of 195 cases have been referred to the Adjudication Panel for England between October 2002 and February this year. Of those 173 have been determined. The remaining 22 cases have yet to be determined. The following table shows the breakdown by month:

Number of cases
2002
October 1
November 19
December 25
Total 45
2003
January 15
February 38
March 13
April 9
May 26
June 10
July 4
August 2
September 11
October 7

Number of cases
November 0
December 7
Total 142
2004
January 0
February 8
Total 8

128 cases related to breaches of the requirement to complete the Register of Interests by Parish Councillors. The following table shows the type of complaint made in the remaining cases and the outcome (in some cases more than one type of complaint is raised).

Nature of complaint Number
Failure to promote equality—unlawful discrimination 3
Failure to treat others with respect 21
Compromise impartiality of authority employees 7
Disclosure of confidential information 6
Bringing office or authority into disrepute 37
Using position to confer or secure advantage or disadvantage 14
Failure to use resources in accordance with requirements 7
Failure to report another member 1
Failure to disclose a personal interest 19
Prejudicial interest—failure to withdraw 23
Total 138

In the 173 cases heard to date, the Adjudication Panel found that there had been no breach of the code in six cases, and declined to impose sanctions in a further six. In the other cases Members were disqualified, or suspended as tabled:

Period of disqualification or suspension Number of members
Member disqualified up to 1 month 2
Member disqualified for 1 to 6 months 4
Member disqualified for 1 year 100
Member disqualified for 18 months 4
Member disqualified for 2 years 13
Member disqualified for 3 years 10
Member disqualified for 5 years 3
Member suspended up to 1 month 12
Member suspended 1 to 6 months 10
Member suspended for 1 year 3