HC Deb 13 January 2003 vol 397 cc488-95W
Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what evidence will be required to demonstrate that local people support an application for foundation status. [87747]

Mr. Hutton

The position is set out in paragraph 7.11 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts".

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what requirements there will be for governors of NHS foundation trusts publicly to state their political allegiances. [87748]

Mr. Hutton

This will be a matter for national health service foundation trusts to decide.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what control NHS foundation trusts will have over changes in the level of accident and emergency facilities. [87749]

Mr. Hutton

The position is set out in paragraphs 3.10–3.12 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts". Details will be included in forthcoming legislation.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health with reference to paragraph 1.41 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts", what sorts of organisations could become NHS foundation trusts. [87751]

Mr. Hutton

The position is set out in paragraph 7.3 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts".

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what freedom there will be for NHS foundation trusts to vary pay and conditions for clinical staff outside the Agenda for Change Agreement. [87752]

Mr. Hutton

The position is set out in paragraphs 6.1–6.7 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts". Details will be set out in forthcoming legislation.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health if boards of governors of a NHS foundation trust will be able to remove members of a management board. [87774]

Mr. Hutton

New legislation will set out the provisions for both appointment and dismissal of members of the management board.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health who will determine whether(a) a chair and (b) a non-executive director of a management board of a NHS foundation trust meets criteria laid down by the independent regulator; and what will happen if a person is elected as (i) a chair and (ii) a non-executive director but does not meet those criteria. [87777]

Mr. Hutton

A national health service foundation trust will set its own criteria for elections of these individuals taking into account guidance from the independent regulator and statutory requirements. A person who does not meet the NHS foundation trust's criteria would not be eligible for election.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether there will be a mechanism for appeal against a decision of the independent regulator on matters relating to NHS foundation trusts. [87780]

Mr. Hutton

Arrangements will be set out in forthcoming legislation.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether he will have a power of direction over the independent regulator for NHS foundation trusts. [87781]

Mr. Hutton

No.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health pursuant to his statement of 11 December 2002,Official Report column, 272, if he will make a statement on the meaning of creation of a legal lock on the assets of NHS foundation trusts. [87782]

Mr. Hutton

National health service foundation trusts will be prevented from selling and distributing assets necessary for the continued provision of essential services.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what estimates he has made of the costs to a NHS foundation trust of(a) setting up and (b) administering a membership register. [87783]

Mr. Hutton

The Department of Health will work with second stage applicants to prepare for formal establishment, including practical support to develop the new governance arrangements.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether local authorities will be able to appoint members to the board of governors of an NHS foundation trust. [87787]

Mr. Hutton

The constitution of a national health service foundation trust will set out the arrangements for appointing representatives of partner organisations to the board of governors. The minimum requirements are set out in paragraph 2.17 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts". As explained in paragraphs 2.17–2.23 there will be flexibility for each NHS foundation trust to decide whether to include other partner organisations, including local authority social service departments.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what his estimate is of the costs of setting up an Independent Regulator for NHS foundation trusts. [87788]

Mr. Hutton

Costs will depend on the roles and responsibilities of the Independent Regulator, which will be set out in forthcoming legislation and on the number of national health service foundation trusts.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether it is his policy that borrowing by an NHS foundation trust from the private sector may be guaranteed by(a) the Secretary of State for Health, (b) strategic health authorities, (c) primary care trusts and (d) other bodies within the NHS. [87789]

Mr. Hutton

The regime for managing financial failure in national health service foundation trusts will safeguard the Secretary of State's overriding priority—that NHS patients continue to have access to the health care they need, free at the point of delivery. The regime will not underwrite institutions that have failed to deliver under the terms of their service agreements and/or licence.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether an NHS foundation trust will be able to carry out work for NHS patients without charge. [87790]

Mr. Hutton

National health service foundation trusts will provide services that are free at the point of use according to clinical need, not the ability to pay.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health if boards of governors of NHS foundation trusts will be able to take independent advice on matters, with particular reference to the requirement to advise the management board on the trust's forward plans. [87810]

Mr. Hutton

It is for the board of governors of each national health service foundation trust to determine what advice it requires in order to carry out its responsibilities. Any provision for allocation of resources to the board of governors will be determined by the NHS foundation trust's constitution.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what the policy of primary care trusts will need to be towards a foundation trust application to allow such an application to go forward; and which PCTs will be entitled to have their view considered. [87811]

Mr. Hutton

The position is set out in paragraph 7.11 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts". We will work with short-listed applicants to identify the relevant primary care trusts.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what consultation he has had with the Office for National Statistics about the classification of NHS foundation trusts in the national accounts; and what advice he received. [87812]

Mr. Hutton

None.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health how he defines suitable comfort in relation to private finance initiative schemes for NHS foundation trusts, as mentioned in paragraph 5.22 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts". [87813]

Mr. Hutton

For national health service trusts with existing private finance initiative (PFI) projects, suitable comfort means that legislation introducing NHS foundation trusts must not affect any new NHS foundation trust's ability to meet its obligations under its PFI contract. Legislation will also ensure that NHS foundation trusts, once created, will be able to sponsor their own PFI projects using the same legislative framework as NHS trusts.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether an NHS foundation trust may appear within the private sector in the national accounts. [87814]

Mr. Hutton

This is a matter for the Office for National Statistics.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether the Government will act as the lender of last resort for NHS foundation trusts if they are unable to borrow from private sector sources. [87815]

Mr. Hutton

The arrangements for borrowing by national health service foundation trusts are set out in paragraph 5.13–5.16 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts".

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether there will be age criteria for membership of an NHS foundation trust. [87816]

Mr. Hutton

The criteria for membership are set out in paragraph 2.6 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts".

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether the amounts due under private finance initiative contracts will be treated as borrowing for the purpose of the borrowing limits to be set for NHS foundation trusts. [87818]

Mr. Hutton

No. The contract with a private finance initiative project company is for a service, and as such, does not constitute borrowing.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether NHS foundation trusts will be able to transfer their existing assets as part of a private finance initiative transaction. [87819]

Mr. Hutton

National health service foundation trusts will continue to be able to procure capital schemes using the private finance initiative process, subject to the same degree of oversight as applies under current arrangements.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether NHS foundation trusts will be able to carry out work for private patients through the medium of(a) subsidiary companies and (b) public private partnership arrangements. [87820]

Mr. Hutton

Subject to compliance with licence conditions explained in paragraph 3.14–3.15 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts", national health service foundation trusts will be able to carry out work for private patients through a range of corporate arrangements.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether membership of an NHS foundation trust will be available to persons who live in(a) Scotland and (b) Wales. [87821]

Mr. Hutton

Subject to legislation, membership will be open to residents in Scotland and Wales if they meet the eligibility criteria set by a national health service foundation trust.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what freedom the Independent Regulator will have to interpret the terms(a) 'NHS standards' and (b) 'NHS values' when deciding to (i) issue and (ii) monitor NHS foundation trust licences. [87822]

Mr. Hutton

The role and responsibilities of the Independent Regulator will be set out in forthcoming legislation.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what provision there will be for the elections to boards of governors of NHS foundation trusts. [87823]

Mr. Hutton

The position is set out in paragraphs 2.25–2.28 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts". Details will be included in forthcoming legislation.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health who will assume control of a foundation trust which is dissolved; and how services will continue to be provided in that case. [87824]

Mr. Hutton

The position is set out in paragraph 3.38 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts". Details will be included in forthcoming legislation.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health from when care trusts will be eligible for establishment as NHS foundation trusts. [87825]

Mr. Hutton

The position is set out in paragraph 7.3 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts".

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health if a person will need to be on the electoral register in order to register as a member of an NHS foundation trust. [87826]

Mr. Hutton

The criteria for membership are set out in paragraph 2.6 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts".

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health who will draw up each foundation trust's statement of purpose; what legal status a statement will have; and what powers the Secretary of State will have to alter such statements. [87827]

Mr. Hutton

Details will be set out in each national health service foundation trust's constitution subject to requirements in forthcoming legislation (see paragraph 3.5 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts"). The Secretary of State will have no power to alter a NHS foundation trust's statement of purpose.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what definition he uses of the term protection of the public interest in paragraph 1.16 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts". [87828]

Mr. Hutton

Protecting the public interest in this context refers to safeguards that will ensure the continued provision of essential public services and prevent distribution of the assets necessary for the continued provision of those services.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health whether an NHS foundation trust will be able to invest surplus financial assets as it wishes. [87877]

Mr. Hutton

The position is explained in paragraph 3.5 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts". Details will be set out in forthcoming legislation.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health when he will publish the prudential code referred to in paragraph 5.17 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts". [87878]

Mr. Hutton

The position is set out in paragraph 3.17 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts".

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what assessment he has made of the willingness of the private sector to lend money for capital projects to NHS foundation trusts in the absence of security on the related assets. [87879]

Mr. Hutton

There has been widespread consultation with the financial community throughout the development of the national health service foundation trust policy. Lenders are not looking to take security over assets crucial to the provision of essential public services. NHS foundation trusts will borrow primarily on the strength of their projected cash flows.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health how the strict limits on the provision by NHS foundation hospitals of services to private patients referred to in paragraph 3.4 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts" will be defined; and whether it will be possible for an NHS foundation hospital to apply for a revision to the limits. [87889]

Mr. Hutton

The position is set out in paragraph 3.15 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts". The limit will not be subject to revision. Details will be included in forthcoming legislation.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what calculations he has made of the potential membership communities for NHS foundation hospitals situated in(a) London and (b) other large urban areas. [87890]

Mr. Hutton

The membership community will vary across national health service foundation trusts and it will be up to each applicant to set out boundaries on the basis of minimum criteria to be set out in forthcoming legislation.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health if an NHS foundation trust will be required to charge standard tariffs for each area of its activity. [87894]

Mr. Hutton

The position is set out in paragraphs 5.6–5.12 and 5.25–5.29 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts".

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health how it will be determined what portion of debt of an NHS trust is associated with particular assets that are transferred. [87895]

Mr. Hutton

The intention is that on establishment a national health service foundation trust will inherit the balance sheet of its predecessor NHS trust. Assets will be transferred at the value shown in the accounts of NHS trust.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health which council is referred to in paragraph 2.22 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts". [87896]

Mr. Hutton

The term "council" should read "board of governors".

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what the statutory responsibilities of(a) member of a board of governors, (b) chair of a board of governors, (c) chair of a management board, (d) non-executive director of a management board and (e) executive member of a management board of an NHS foundation trust will be. [87897]

Mr. Hutton

The statutory responsibilities of these individuals will be set out in forthcoming legislation.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what resources will be available to boards of governors of NHS foundation hospitals to enable them to carry out their functions. [87898]

Mr. Hutton

Subject to legislation, this will be a matter for the national health service foundation trust to determine.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health how the level of(a) financial and (b) other resources available to the independent regulator for NHS foundation hospitals will be determined. [87899]

Mr. Hutton

Provision for the establishment of the independent regulator, including funding, will be set out in forthcoming legislation.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health for what reasons NHS foundation trusts will not be able to use their regulated assets as security for borrowing. [87900]

Mr. Hutton

National health service foundation trusts will not be allowed to use their regulated assets as security against borrowing to ensure the continuity of essential services in the event of financial failure.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health what is meant by public interest mandate in paragraph 5.24 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts". [87901]

Mr. Hutton

Public interest mandate in this context refers to the public interest duties that will be enshrined in the licence of each national health service foundation trust that are described in paragraph 3.5 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts".

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health in what ways the independent regulator for NHS foundation trusts will he independent of the Secretary of State for Health. [87903]

Mr. Hutton

The independent regulator will not be subject to direction by the Secretary of State for Health.

Dr. Fox

To ask the Secretary of State for Health if it is his policy to ensure that the board of governors of a NHS foundation trust is not dominated by(a) a particular group of members and (b) a sectional interest. [87904]

Mr. Hutton

Yes, paragraphs 2.17–2.28 of "A Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts" set out clearly that national health service foundation trusts will need to establish a properly representative public and patient membership base and set up a board of governors that is balanced and representative of the whole membership community.

Forward to