HC Deb 18 December 2003 vol 415 cc1032-8W
Sue Doughty

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs how she plans to reduce spending pressures on local government in respect of waste next year, as announced in the statement by the right hon. Member for Greenwich and Woolwich (Mr. Raynsford),Official Report, 19 November 2003, column 786. [143316]

Mr. Morley

[holding answer 10 December 2003]: We have announced that we are putting back the start date of the Landfill Allowance Trading Scheme to 2005. This is consistent with the views expressed by local authorities in the recent consultation on the implementation of the scheme. It will reduce spending pressures by around £10m overall.

The Department is looking urgently at the options for meeting the remainder of its commitment to relieve spending pressures, and will be making an announcement shortly.

Alistair Burt

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs what advice her Department gave his constituent, Mr. Ross Donovan, in relation to his company's compliance with Directive 2000/76/EC on the Incineration of Waste when he first contacted her Department; when this advice changed; and what advice her Department is currently able to give. [143854]

Mr. Morley

The Department's first contact with Mr. Donovan, (who is the hon. Member's constituent and not the Secretary of State's) and his company was on 19 September 2003. Mr. Donovan had previously had discussions with the Environment Agency and attended a meeting at the Agency's Huntingdon office on 24 July 2003. During that meeting, Mr. Donovan was advised that there was a possibility that his plant would be subject to the Waste Incineration Directive and the Pollution Prevention and Control (England and Wales) Regulations 2000 (the PPC Regulations). Following the meeting, this advice was confirmed in a letter to Mr. Donovan of 13 August 2003. The letter also stated that the plant may fall within the regulatory remit of the appropriate local authority in England and Wales or the Scottish Environmental Protection Agency (SEPA), depending on where the plant would be located.

Prior to transposition of the Waste Incineration Directive at the end of 2002 it was difficult for the Environment Agency to be able to provide firm advice to every operator on whether they would be subject to it However, my Department consulted on draft Regulations and Directions during the summer of 2002. The transposition of the Waste Incineration Directive and the publication by my Department of draft "Guidance on the Directive 2000/76/EC on the Incineration of Waste" was publicised through articles in the trade press and at a ministerial press conference in January 2003.

A group of my officials visited Mr. Donovan on 12 November 2003 to consider his case, at which time he was again advised that it was possible that his plant would be subject to the Waste Incineration Directive and the PPC Regulations. Following the visit and further consideration of Mr. Donovan's plant by my officials working with the Environment Agency, I will write to the hon. Member shortly with the outcome.

Mrs. Spelman

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs what measures she is taking to ensure that the polluter pays principle applies to the(a) collection of and (b) management of municipal waste. [143281]

Mr. Morley

The Waste Framework Directive (75/442/EEC as amended by 91/156/EEC) sets out a range of measures on the management of waste including its collection and disposal. These measures include Article 8 which requires that "any holder of waste has it handled by a private or public waste collector"; and Article 15 which provides that "In accordance with the 'polluter pays' principle, the cost of disposing of waste must be borne by the holder who has it handled by a waste collector."

The Government have put a range of measures in place under Part II of the Environmental Protection Act 1990, the Controlled Waste Regulations 1992 and the Waste Management Licensing Regulations 1994 to comply with the Directive's requirements. These measures include the arrangements for the collection and disposal of household waste by waste collection and disposal authorities. The cost of collection and disposal under these arrangements is met through taxation and charges. Most commercial and industrial waste is collected and disposed of by the private sector under arrangements which comply with the Directive. The cost of collection and disposal under these arrangement is met through charges.

Municipal waste includes household waste and any other wastes collected by a waste collection authority or its agents under Part II of the 1990 Act (Waste Strategy 2000 page 198 (Cm 4693–2)).

Mrs. Spelman

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs which 10 local authorities had the(a) highest and (b) lowest recycling rates in the last year for which figures are available. [143282]

Mr. Morley

The percentage of household waste recycled and composted by the 10 highest and lowest performing local authorities, for which the most recent data available are 2001–02, is presented in the following table.

Local authority Percentage of household waste recycled and composted in 2001–02
Daventry District Council 43.7
Lichfield District Council 32.8
Eastleigh Borough Council 29.5
Forest Heath District Council 29.2
St. Edmundsbury Borough Council 29.1
Dorset County Council 27.2
Chiltern District Council 26.8
Melton Borough Council 26.1
Bath and North East Somerset Council 24.9
New Forest District Council 23.6
Trafford Metropolitan Borough Council 2.2
Liverpool City Council Metropolitan Borough Council 2.1
Rochdale Metropolitan Borough Council 2.0
Bolsover District Council 1.9
North Cornwall District Council 1.8
Redcar and Cleveland Borough Council 1.6
Cannock Chase Council 1.6
Sunderland City Council 1.3
Hackney London Borough 1.2
London Corporation 0.1
1Municipal Waste Management Survey 2001–02.

Mrs. Spelman

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs what high temperature incineration capacity she estimates the UK will require when provisions of the Landfill Directive relating to hazardous waste are implemented in the UK. [143283]

Mr. Morley

Current high temperature incineration capacity (HTI) in the UK is approximately 110,000 tonnes per annum. Work undertaken for the Hazardous Waste Forum suggests that the demand for HTI is likely to increase, but that the level of any increase is dependent on a number of factors, not least future arisings of hazardous waste. The Forum continues to keep these issues under review, in particular through the treatment and capacity task force.

Mrs. Spelman

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs what additional(a) recycling, (b) composting, (c) energy recovery and (d) hazardous waste treatment capacity will be required in England to achieve compliance with the Landfill Directive in (a) 2009, (b) 2013 and (c) 2020. [143284]

Mr. Morley

Waste Strategy 2000 provided five estimates of waste management options over the period 2000 to 2020. A 'base case' was modelled so that the additional cost of meeting the landfill targets for biodegradable waste and the waste strategy goals could be calculated. The other four models provided different mixes of recycling, composting and incineration and the additional capacity required for those facilities under each option.

Cases 3 and 4 (increasing levels of recycling and composting with some incineration with energy recovery) were designed to meet the waste strategy targets, as well as the requirements of the Landfill Directive.

The actual figures for additional capacity can be seen in annex C in Part Two of Waste Strategy 2000 (table C8 on page 194). A copy of the strategy is in the House of Common's Library and can also be accessed through the Defra website at: www.defra.gov.uk/environment/waste/strategy/cm4693/index.htm.

Future hazardous waste treatment capacity required under the Landfill Directive depends in part on future arisings of hazardous waste. Currently some 5 million tonnes of hazardous waste is consigned each year in England and Wales. Analysis in support of the Hazardous Waste Forum shows that future arisings of hazardous waste will be affected, among other matters, by future levels of waste minimisation balanced against changes to the hazardous waste list. Nevertheless, the Landfill Directive requires all hazardous waste to be treated prior to landfill or to be dealt with in an alternative treatment option altogether, such as high temperature incineration or co-incineration. It is clear that new treatment plants for hazardous waste will be required, for example to solidify waste, and to enable hazardous waste to meet the landfill waste acceptance criteria under the Directive. The Hazardous Waste Forum is considering these issues and requirements in detail through its treatment and capacity task force.

Mrs. Spelman:

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs how many tonnes of (a) glass, (b) paper, (c) wood, (d) plastic and (e) metal containers were recycled by community organisations in (i) 2000, (ii) 2001 and (iii) 2002; what the average cost per tonne was; and if she will make a statement on how their performance was audited. [143286]

Mr. Morley

As part of Defra's Municipal Waste Management Survey, local authorities are asked to submit any data on recycling carried out by community organisations in their area, that they are aware of. The responses for 2000–01 and 2001–02 are shown in the table. The data are not believed to be comprehensive.

Voluntary/private collections
Material recycled in thousand tonnes 2000–01 2001–02
Paper and card 24 13
Glass 1 1
Compost 1 1
Scrap metal and white goods 0 0
Textiles 4 1
Cans 0 0
Plastics 0 0
Co-mingled 2 4
Other (inc. oils, batteries, aluminiumfoil, books and shoes) 4 14
Total 35 34

The Community Recycling Network, a national umbrella organisation for community and not-for-profit waste management groups claims that their members account for approximately 7 per cent. of the total material collected from households for recycling in the UK.

This Department does not collect the requested cost data nor does it audit the performance of community waste organisations.

Mrs. Spelman

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs what discussions her Department has had with representatives of the waste management sector on incorporating combined heat and power in new developments. [143287]

Mr. Bradshaw

The Department recognises that CHP has a part to play in effective waste management, as demonstrated in the recent changes to the criteria applied to waste PFI projects. These were in direct response to the views of the market and the waste management sector will be invited to contribute to a wider review of the criteria which is now in train.

We also provide direct support to energy from waste projects through our Community Energy programme, delivering community heating mainly through the use of CHP. Meetings with the waste management sector have resulted in five energy from waste schemes receiving more than £2.5m or over 10 per cent. of the funding awarded.

Mrs. Spelman

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs how much public money has been spent on collecting and managing municipal waste in the United Kingdom in each year since 1997; and how much on average it cost to collect and manage one tonne of municipal waste in the UK in each year since 1997. [143291]

Mr. Morley

Annual net current expenditure by English waste authorities for providing the services of collection and disposal of municipal waste are taken from annual ODPM Local Authority Revenue Outturn Returns. Annual municipal waste arisings are taken from the Defra Municipal Waste Management Survey.

The data are listed as follows are for the financial years 1997–98 to 2001–02 and are for English local authorities. An average net cost of managing one tonne of municipal waste has been estimated based on this data. Financial data exclude any capital charges.

Financial year (a) Municipal waste arisings (thousand tones) (b) Net current expenditure (£000) (b/a) Cost to manage one tonne of municipal waste (£
1997–98 25,711 1,198,880 46.63
1998–99 26,337 1,281,919 48.67
1999–2000 27,480 1,423,278 51.79
2000–01 28,057 1,521,338 54.22
2001–02 28,823 1,653,856 57.38

Alan Simpson

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs in what circumstances solid polychlorinated biphenyls can be(a) landfilled and (b) incinerated. [143506]

Mr. Morley

Wastes contaminated with polychlorinated biphenyls (RGBs) can only be landfilled where the authorisation allows it. Limit values apply to all deposits of PCB contaminated waste and are given in Government guidance (Waste Management Paper No 6—"Polychlorinated Biphenyls").Additionally, implementation of the Landfill Directive will subject any solid PCB contaminated waste to the pre-treatment requirements and waste acceptance criteria.

Similarly, PCBs can be incinerated in hazardous waste incinerators which have been authorised to burn such wastes. These incinerators are required to meet the stringent emission limits specified in the Hazardous Waste Incineration Directive (94/67/EC).

Mrs. Spelman

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs what the rate of landfill tax is in other member states of the European Union where such a tax is levied. [143290]

Mr. Morley

The Strategy Unit Report 'Waste not, Want not' published in November 2002 contained the following table:

European Union state Tax rates (£/tonne)
Austria 18–54
Belgium 3–14
Denmark 28
Finland 9
France 4
Germany None
Greece None
Ireland None
Italy 0.6–16
Luxembourg None
Netherlands 8–40
Portugal None
Spain None
Sweden 17
UK 2–13

Note:

Figures are approximate due to rounding. Figures represent the latest years available and may not be consistent between countries.

Average household water bill
£
1996–97 1997–98 1998–99 1999–2000 2000–01 2001–02 2002–03 2003–04
Water and sewerage companies
Anglian 128 126 124 116 107 110 113 116
Hartlepool 88 91 96 95
Dwr Cymru 128 135 136 134 126 123 124 122
North West 93 99 101 103 103 107 109 118
Northumbrian 96 98 102 100 88 88 88 90
Essex and Suffolk 116 120 127 129 107 112 111 113
Severn Trent 88 97 105 113 106 108 108 112
South West 127 129 125 119 109 110 115 121
Southern 94 101 105 111 91 91 90 91
Thames 88 93 99 102 95 99 104 106
Wessex 114 118 124 124 107 112 113 119
Yorkshire 104 105 108 111 100 103 104 110
York 87 89 93 96 87 90 90 94
Water only companies
Bournemouth and W. Hampshire 94 97 103 102 99 98 101 102
Bristol 100 104 108 111 101 105 106 107
Cambridge 103 106 106 98 86 87 90 94
Cholderton 126 130 151 136 130 141 153 143
Dee Valley 120 107 106 104 106
Chester 106 108 108
Wrexham 130 129 129
Folkestone and Dover 114 118 116 117 118 125 125 135
Mid Kent 131 135 141 146 117 123 127 128
Portsmouth 72 72 73 74 74 75 75 76
South East 118 114 121 126
South East 156 155 158 159
Mid Southern 114 115 116 120

Sources:

OECD, ENDS and Austrian Federal Environment Agency, 2002

Forward to