HC Deb 27 June 2002 vol 387 cc1047-8W
Matthew Taylor

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will place the accounting advice given by the Office for National Statistics concerning Network Rail in the Library; and if he will make a statement. [65059]

Mr. Boateng

Yes, the letter from the Office for National statistics of 20 June 2002 giving accounting advice concerning Network Rail will be placed in the Library.

Mr. Howard

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what assessment he has made of the impact of the treatment of Network Rail debt on potential UK obligations under EMU convergence programmes and the stability and growth pact. [64880]

Mr. Boateng

Network Rail will be classified to the private sector in national accounts. It would pose no threat to UK obligations under EU treaties that concern excessive government deficits.

Mr. Howard

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what submissions his Department has made to the ONS about the treatment of Network Rail debt in the national accounts; and if he will set out the reasoning behind those submissions. [64881]

Mr. Boateng

Over the months since October 2001 Treasury has kept ONS informed about the developing proposals for the constitution and financing of Network Rail in order to give ONS the opportunity to ask questions affecting the sector classification.

Year started contributing Retire at end year Years of contribution Lump sum built up (£) Lump sum in 2000 earnings terms (£) Annuity rate in last year of contribution Pension at retirement (nominal terms, £ weekly) Pension at retirement (2000 earnings terms, £ weekly)
1956 1986 31 17,681 38.694 14.1 48 105
1957 1987 31 21,066 42,786 14.0 57 115
1958 1988 31 23,845 44,503 13.7 63 117
1959 1989 31 25,578 43,792 14.0 69 118
1960 1990 31 27,866 43,460 15.2 82 127
1961 1991 31 34,243 49,608 14.6 96 139
1962 1992 31 41,169 56,297 13.2 105 143
1963 1993 31 53,666 71,268 11.7 121 161
1964 1994 31 47,497 60,865 11.6 106 135
1965 1995 31 57,034 70,893 11.3 124 154
1966 1996 31 60,718 72,850 11.0 129 154
1967 1997 31 71,040 81,762 10.4 141 163
1968 1998 31 85,598 93,743 9.4 155 169
1969 1999 31 80,168 83,738 8.9 138 144
1970 2000 31 85,438 85,438 9.1 149 149
1971 2001 31 83,936 80,348 8.9 143 137

The figures are based on hypothetical modelling of the return from contributing to a pension fund using the following assumptions: A person contributes to a personal pension for 31 years. The earnings of each individual go up in line with average earnings.

On 14 June 2002 Treasury wrote to ONS asking for a formal decision on the sector classification of Network Rail in national accounts. ONS replied on 20 June saying that, subject to NR's members confirming the board of directors, and further checking of the legal documents, NR would be classified to the private sector in national accounts. The reasoning behind the submissions was to obtain ONS' s view on the sector classification of Network Rail, and to make sure that ONS received in good time all the information it needed to make that decision and raise any queries.

Mr. Howard

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer what discussions he has had with the Department for Transport about the treatment of Network Rail debt in the national accounts. [64872]

Mr. Boateng

Treasury officials have advised the Department for Transport that the Office for National Statistics (ONS) would classify Network Rail (NR) to the private sector in national accounts once its board of directors had been confirmed by a meeting of NR's members.