HC Deb 25 February 2002 vol 380 cc866-70W
Mr. Woodward

To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry how many home visits for medical assessment purposes to former miners have been conducted in (a) St. Helens, South, (b) Merseyside, (c) the north-west, (d) England, (e) Scotland and (f) Wales for (i) vibration white finger and (ii) respiratory diseases. [35586]

Mr. Wilson

The number of domiciliary visits undertaken in those regions is as follows:

Number of vibration white finger domiciliary visits Number of respiratory disease domiciliary visits
(a) St. Helens South 1 15
(b) Merseyside 5 33
(c) North-west 28 173
(d) England 201 1,815
(e) Scotland 48 389
(f) Wales 63 982

Mr. Woodward

To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry how many former miners' compensation claims for(a) respiratory disease and (b) vibration white finger have been prioritised in (i) St. Helens, South, (ii) Merseyside, (iii) the north-west, (iv) England, (v) Scotland and (vi) Wales. [35585]

Mr. Wilson

The number of high priority respiratory disease claimants who have been prioritised and medically assessed is as follows:

Region Number
St. Helens, South 46
Merseyside 129
North-west 591
England 7,278
Scotland 871
Wales 3,400

The Department is unable, in the time given, to provide a breakdown of prioritised priority vibration white finger, VWF, claims. However, GB-wide, 346 claimants have been prioritised and received domiciliary visits.

Mr. Woodward

To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what estimate the Government have made of the number of claims for(a) vibration white

Regional breakdown of number of new claims for vibration white finger
2001 St. Helens, South Merseyside North-west England Scotland Wales
January 1 8 46 812 47 56
February 3 10 30 723 24 84
March 8 14 63 1,574 39 104
April 2 35 132 1,763 112 128
May 2 6 31 1,370 91 89
June 1 14 50 1,323 80 108
July 2 15 64 1,398 93 95
August 1 8 37 1,255 49 76
September 2 16 59 1,068 55 103
October 6 23 71 1,544 173 195
November 11 37 107 2,183 138 95
December 8 22 61 1,108 93 75

finger and (b) respiratory diseases for (i) former miners, (ii) widows of former miners and (iii) other eligible estate claims for former miners in (A) St. Helens South, (B) Merseyside, (C) the north-west, (D) England, (E) Scotland and (F) Wales. [35590]

Mr. Wilson

The Department has received nationally 177,000 claims in respect of respiratory disease and 135,000 in relation to vibration white finger, VWF. The Department continues to receive over 600 new respiratory disease claims and over 360 new VWF claims per week. As such, the Department is unable to provide an estimate of the number of claims to be received on either scheme.

Mr. Woodward

To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry what the average waiting time has been for former miners for an appointment for a medical assessment for(a) respiratory disease and (b) vibration white finger in (i) north-west England, (ii) Scotland and (iii) Wales in the last 12 months. [35589]

Mr. Wilson

Claims are being processed according to priority as set out in the handling agreement. The average waiting time between completion of medical records recovery and an appointment to undergo a medical assessment is as follows:

(a) Respiratory disease
Average waiting time in days
(i) North-west (ii) Scotland (iii) Wales
Live cases 76 48 123
Deceased cases 39 56 52

(b) Vibration white finger
(i) North-west (ii) Scotland (iii) Wales
Average waiting time in days 86 47 53

Mr. Woodward

To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry how many new claims were lodged by former miners for(a) vibration white finger and (b) respiratory diseases by month throughout 2001, in (i) St. Helens, South, (ii) Merseyside, (iii) the north-west,(iv) England, (v) Scotland and (vi) Wales. [35591]

Mr. Wilson

New claims were registered as follows:

Regional breakdown of number of new claims for respiratory disease
2001 St. Helens, South Merseyside North-west England Scotland Wales
January 14 29 115 3,783 341 906
February 15 49 114 2,485 271 768
March 15 52 187 3,658 217 1,280
April 27 62 156 2,461 188 480
May 21 54 152 2,972 365 659
June 11 33 114 3,551 245 278
July 14 32 145 3,088 259 274
August 13 34 152 2,629 183 328
September 14 46 146 3,074 193 409
October 32 103 339 3,544 184 503
November 50 136 343 2,379 227 279
December 19 63 161 1,637 151 169

Mr. Woodward

To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry how many expedited payments were made to former miners with respiratory diseases in(a) St. Helens, South, (b) Merseyside, (c) the north-west, (d) England, (e) Scotland and (f) Wales; and what the average expedited payment award was in each case. [35588]

Mr. Wilson

The number and average expedited payments were made in the above regions as follows:

Region Number of expedited payments Average payment £
(a) St. Helens, South 40 3,978
(b) Merseyside 146 4,464
(c) North-west 674 4,523
(d) England 8,661 4,117
(e) Scotland 943 4,424
(f) Wales 1,201 3,630

Mr. Woodward

To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry how many former miners pursuing compensation claims have had a medical assessment for(a) respiratory diseases and (b) vibration white finger in (i) St. Helens, South (ii) Merseyside, (iii) the north-west, (iv) England, (v) Scotland and (vi) Wales. [35587]

Mr. Wilson

The number of miners who have attended an appointment to undergo the medical assessment is as follows:

Number of miners1 Number of miners2
St. Helens, South 330 207
Merseyside 790 681
north-west 3,234 2,328
England 37,055 62,326
Scotland 7,326 4,069
Wales 17,945 8,814
1 Who have attended a respiratory disease medical assessment
2 Who have attended a Vibration White Finger medical assessment

Mr. Barron

To ask the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry how much has been paid to claimants through each of the top 10 claims handlers involved in the compensation claims for(a) chronic bronchitis and emphysema and (b) vibration white finger of former coalminers. [37424]

Mr. Wilson

The amount paid to claimants through each of the top 10 claims handlers for respiratory disease and Vibration White Finger is as follows.

(£ million)
Solicitor Total damages paid
Respiratory Disease
Thompsons 62.2
Hugh James Ford Simey 47.6
Union of Democratic Mineworkers 16.1
Raleys 27.4
Mark Gilbert Morse 4.3
Browell Smith & Co 20.9
Graysons 10.1
Watson Burton 7.2
Irwin Mitchells 12.4
Randell Saunders 3.3
Total 211.3
Vibration White Finger
Thompsons 70.1
Browell Smith & Co 40.5
Union of Democratic Mineworkers 43.8
Raleys 28.5
Hugh James Ford Simey 28.6
Graysons 22.0
Moss 14.2
Watson Burton 23.1
AMS Law 12.8
Towells 16.6
Total 300.4