§ Mr. PatersonTo ask the Secretary of State for Health when Professor Sir John Krebs was first informed about problems at Mead Webber; by whom; and what action he took. [122067]
§ Ms Stuart[holding answer 15 May 2000]I am advised by the Food Standards Agency that Ms Suzi Leather, the agency's deputy chair, was fully informed of the situation at Mead Webber by the chief executive of the Meat Hygiene Service (MHS) on Saturday 22 April. Ms Suzi Leather and Professor Sir John Krebs, Chairman of the Food Standards Agency, discussed the situation at this plant with the chief executives of the Meat Hygiene Service and the Food Standards Agency over the following week.
The MHS is an executive agency of the Food Standards Agency and the Food Standards Agency holds the Chief Executive of the MHS responsible for the operation and management of the MHS and its staff. Given the concerns expressed about the Mead Webber closure, Professor Sir John Krebs has taken and maintains a close interest in the situation at the plant, and was as a consequence fully informed of the outcome of a meeting which took place on Sunday 30 April between the Chief Executive of the MHS and Dr. Richard North, Food Safety Adviser representing Mead Webber Ltd. At this meeting, it was agreed that, given Mead Webber Ltd.'s concerns:
An independent investigation into the actions of the Meat Hygiene Service at the Mead Webber plant would take place;The outcome of this independent investigation would be placed in the public domain; andNo Hygiene Assessment System score would be published for the plant for the first month after re-opening, to enable plant management and the Meat Hygiene Service to work constructively together to address any remaining concerns.
§ Mr. PatersonTo ask the Secretary of State for Health what conclusions had been reached by Official Veterinary Surgeons in the five years prior to 10 April on the acceptability of trimming by meat inspectors at the Mead Webber plant. [122060]
578W
§ Ms Stuart[holding answer 15 May 2000]I am advised by the Food Standards Agency that there is no formal record of the conclusions reached by official veterinary surgeons (OVSs) in the five years prior to 10 April 2000 on the acceptability of trimming by meat inspectors at the plant operated by Mead Webber Ltd.
The Meat Hygiene Service's policy and instruction to inspection staff on carcase trimming is detailed in the MHS Operations Manual, Chapter 6, Page 4. It states:
Carcases and offal presented for inspection with evidence of visible contamination must be appropriately trimmed to your satisfaction before application of the health mark. Trimming of contamination is normally a task for premises staff working under your direction. However, you may trim minor contamination provided it does not interfere with the inspection routine. Where this cannot be done on the dressing line the affected carcase or offal must be detained for more detailed attention.
§ Mr. PatersonTo ask the Secretary of State for Health if Mr. Yogaratnam of the Meat Hygiene Service had sole responsibility for the Mead Webber plant; to whom in the MHS he reported; what responsibilities he had in respect of other plants at the time he had responsibility for Mead Webber; and how many other plants he had responsibility for. [122054]
§ Ms Stuart[holding answer 15 May 2000]I am advised by the Food Standards Agency that Mr. Yogaratnam was the official veterinary surgeon (OVS) and principal official veterinary surgeon (POVS) for the Mead Webber plant, and as such had sole responsibility for ensuring its full compliance with public health and animal welfare regulations. While contract OVSs were used to provide locum cover during the times that Mr. Yogaratnam carried out his POVS duties, they reported to Mr. Yogaratnam as the responsible OVS and POVS for the Mead Webber abattoir.
Mr. Yogaratnam reported to his line manager, Mr. Ivor Pumfrey, Meat Hygiene Service Regional Director (Wales). Mr. Yogaratnam's technical line manager was Mr. Peter Soul, MHS Director of Operations.
Mr. Yogaratnam was also OVS and POVS at three licensed cutting premises. Mr. Yogaratnam was POVS for 16 other plants in the area. As a POVS he was responsible for contract performance management of Contract OVSs working in 10 other plants in the area.
§ Mr. PatersonTo ask the Secretary of State for Health for what reason the faxed communication of 24 April from Mr. Webber of Mead Webber to the chief executive of the Meat Hygiene Service asking for an explanation of the changes in the MHS's trimming policy was not(a) acknowledged and (b) answered. [122068]
§ Ms Stuart[holding answer 15 May 2000]I am advised by the Food Standards Agency that as Monday 24 April 2000 was a Bank Holiday, the Meat Hygiene Service offices were closed. Following this, the chief executive of the Meat Hygiene Service was due to be on annual leave until 2 May. However, having been made aware of the situation at the plant operated by Mead Webber Ltd., he returned early and on 28 April 2000 answered Mr. Webber's undated fax which had been sent on 24 April 2000.
579WIn his response, the chief executive of the Meat Hygiene Service acknowledged receipt of the fax sent by Mr. Webber and informed him that he had commissioned an investigation into Mr. Webber's concerns and would write again with the conclusions of that investigation.
§ Mr. PatersonTo ask the Secretary of State for Health what brief was given to Mr. John Cartwright by the Meat Hygiene Service prior to his attendance at the Mead Webber plant on 26 April. [122064]
§ Ms Stuart[holding answer 15 May 2000]I am advised by the Food Standards Agency that an independent investigation is to be carried out as soon as possible into the actions of the Meat Hygiene Service at Mead Webber's plant at Eardisley. This will include scrutiny of the actions of Mr. Cartwright.
It would be inappropriate to comment further until this investigation has been completed.
§ Mr. PatersonTo ask the Secretary of State for Health for what reason the prohibition by Mr. Turner of the Meat Hygiene Service on carcase trimming by the meat inspectors at the Mead Webber plant was reversed on 20 April; and by whom and for what reason the decision was subsequently changed again. [122057]
§ Ms Stuart[holding answer 15 May 2000]I am advised by the Food Standards Agency that the Meat Hygiene Service (MHS) have met with a representative of Mead Webber Ltd. and agreed to an independent inquiry into MHS's actions at Mead Webber and the publication of its findings. The events of 20 April 2000 are to be fully investigated as part of that independent investigation. It would be inappropriate to comment further until this investigation has been completed.
§ Mr. PatersonTo ask the Secretary of State for Health for what reason a letter was sent by an official veterinary surgeon to Mead Webber on 19 April concerning remedial works prior to the meeting planned for 26 April; and what account the letter took of remedial works and redecoration already agreed. [122043]
§ Ms Stuart[holding answer 15 May 2000]I am advised by the Food Standards Agency that an investigation is to be carried out as soon as possible into
580W
NHS body Nature of contracts Penalty (£) Trent Region East Midlands Ambulance Service NHS Trust Radio Control System 1,040 Nottingham Health Authority Headquarters Building 1,500 Rotherham General Hospitals NHS Trust Catering 3,000 Queen's Medical Centre, Nottingham University Hospital NHS Trust Laundry Contract Terminated University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust Laundry 1,500 South-West Region Plymouth Hospitals NHS Trust Patient Administration IT System Free extension to service for one quarter (value approx. 300,000) Plymouth Hospitals NHS Trust Cleaning 4,817 Swindon and Marlborough NHS Trust Laundry 22,665 Swindon and Marlborough NHS Trust Radiology services 8,048 West Dorset General Hospitals NHS Trust Estate Maintenance 5,000 Exeter Community Hospitals NHS Trust Cleaning 8,800 South Devon Health Care NHS Trust Laundry Contract Terminated East Somerset NHS Trust Security Contract Terminated and 520 penalty East Somerset NHS Trust Orthotic Services Contract Terminated Poole Hospitals NHS Trust Cleaning 27,500 the actions of the Meat Hygiene Service at Mead Webber's plant at Eardisley. This will involve scrutiny of correspondence.
It would be inappropriate to comment further until this investigation is completed.