§ Mr. McDonnellTo ask the Minister for the Cabinet Office what were the appraisal performance markings awarded to civil servants in 1998 for(a) each agency in his Department and (b) the Department broken down by (i) grade, (ii) gender, (iii) ethnicity, (iv) part-time/ full-time working and (v) disability; and for (1) each agency and (2) the Department whether the Cabinet Office's four fifths rule for detecting potential adverse impact was applied to the appraisal markings of civil servants in the 1998 report round. [78148]
§ Mr. KilfoyleThe information requested is set out in the tables. In the Cabinet Office the appraisal performance marks were analysed by our statisticians who reported that the differences by gender and ethnicity were not statistically significant. The Department is keeping the situation under review. It is committed to a policy of equal opportunity and wishes to ensure that box marking standards reflect that commitment.
303W
Percentage Department/Agency Box 1 Box 2 Box 3 Box 4 Box 5 Cabinet Office Grade SCS 19 55 25 * * Band A 15 50 34 * * Band B 10 49 41 * * Band C 4 49 46 * * all Grades 8 49 42 * * 304W
Percentage Department/Agency Box 1 Box 2 Box 3 Box 4 Box 5 Gender Male 6 41 54 * * Female 11 52 37 * * Ethnicity White 9 51 40 * * Other ethnic origin 6 41 54 * * Part-time/full-time Part-time 4 60 36 * * Full-time 8 46 45 * * Disability Yes * 50 50 * * No 8 47 45 * * CCTA Grade A1 * 100 * * A2 13 57 30 * B1 10 74 16 * B2 9 78 9 3 B3 12 73 15 * C1 9 91 * * C2 29 62 10 * C3 13 87 * * D 20 80 * * all Grades 14 72 14 * Gender Male 13 72 14 * Female 15 73 12 * Ethnicity White 14 73 13 * Other ethnic origin * 80 20 * Part-time/full-time Part-time * 80 20 * Full-time 14 73 13 * Disability Yes 14 73 12 * No 13 50 37 * Civil Service College Grade Zone 1 and 2 8 92 * * Zone 3 6 60 33 * Zone 4 36 64 * * Zone 5 24 68 5 3 Zone 6 9 73 17 * Zone 7 * 36 64 * all Grades 12 66 21 * Gender Male 6 65 28 * Female 16 67 16 * Ethnicity White 12 67 21 * Other ethnic origin 22 44 33 * Part-time/full-time Part-time 5 81 14 * Full-time 14 63 23 * Disability The number of staff with a disability is too small to permit a detailed analysis The Civil Service College is confident that it meets the 4/5ths rule
Percentage Department/Agency Box 1 Box 2 Box 3 Box 4 Box 5 Government Car and Despatch Agency Grade * 86 14 * * The numbers of staff are too small to permit more detailed analysis, including the 4/5ths rule Property Advisers to the Civil Estate Grade Grade 6 * 55 27 18 Grade 7 8 25 38 29 SEO/SPTO * 33 33 33 HEO * 38 48 14 EO * 15 52 33 AO 2 20 46 33 AA * * 50 50 All Grades 2 24 44 30 Gender Male 2 26 41 31 Female * 23 47 29 Ethnicity White 2 25 43 30 Other ethnic origin * 17 44 39 Part-time/full-time Part-time * 20 30 50 Full-time 2 25 45 29 Disability The number of staff with a disability is too small to permit a detailed analysis The 4/5ths rule has not been applied The Buying Agency Grade Band 5/6 17 33 50 * Band 4 * 25 75 * Band 3 * 46 54 * Band 2 * 48 48 4 Band 1 5 28 67 * all Grades 3 36 61 * Gender Male 2 35 63 * Female 4 37 57 2 Ethnicity White 2 38 60 * Other ethnic origin 20 * 80 * Part-time/full-time Part-time * 36 64 * Full-time 3 36 60 * Disability The number of staff with a disability is too small to permit a detailed analysis The 4/5ths rule has not been applied 305W
Percentage Box 1 Box 2 Box 3a Box 3b Box 4 Box 5 Central Office of Information Grade SCS and Directing grades 8 76 8 5 3 * Management A 6 66 26 2 * * Management B 2 54 40 4 * * Management C 11 55 21 13 * * Support A 3 44 46 8 * * Support B * 38 31 25 6 * all Grades 5 58 30 6 * *
Percentage Box 1 Box 2 Box 3a Box 3b Box 4 Box 5 Gender Male 5 58 28 7 * * Female 5 58 31 5 * * Ethnicity White 5 59 29 5 * * Other ethnic origin 5 45 35 15 * * Part-time/full-time Part-time * 60 40 * * * Full-time 5 58 29 7 * * Disability Yes * 43 43 14 * * No 5 59 30 6 * * Note:
The COI has developed its own systems for detecting potential adverse impact in the performance appraisal of its staff. However, retrospective application of the 4/5ths rule confirms that there appears to be no notable bias on the grounds of gender, ethnicity or disability within the limitations imposed by COI's small number of staff.
The COI is a separate department which reports to the Minister for the Cabinet Office.
Percentage A B C D E F G Security Facilities Division (formerly Security Facilities Executive) Grade Grade 7 * 25 50 12 13 * * SEO * 6 41 41 12 * * HEO * 5 17 65 13 * * EO * 4 34 41 21 * * AO * 5 10 33 52 * * AA 4 8 4 24 60 * * All Grades * 6 22 38 33 * * Gender Male * 5 21 41 33 * * Female 3 13 28 25 31 * * Ethnicity White * 7 22 38 33 * * Other ethnic origin * * 18 45 36 * * The numbers of part-time and disabled staff are too small to permit detailed analysis Notes:
The Security Facilities Division was until 1 July 1998 an Executive Agency of the Cabinet Office. It has now been integrated with the Department. Although the 4/5ths rule has not been used in monitoring performance standards, the results have been reviewed to ensure equality and consistency in report marking.
Percentages are rounded to the nearest whole number. Asterisks are used for percentages less than 1.5.
The Cabinet Office and its agencies have each developed their own appraisal systems. In each case the right hand column indicates unacceptable performance and the left hand column outstanding or excellent performance.