§ Mr. Bruce GeorgeTo ask the President of the Board of Trade if she will list the export licences granted to Iraq by Britain since 2 August 1990, separately identifying those for the export of growth medium broken down by (i) size and (ii) value of shipment and by stated end use; what are the current rules controlling the export of growth medium to Iraq; and what changes have been made to them since 2 August 1990. [30919]
§ Mrs. Roche[holding answer 23 February 1998]: The export to Iraq of any goods, unless under authority of an export licence, is prohibited by the Export of Goods (Control)(Iraq and Kuwait Sanctions) Order 1990 [SI 1990/1640], which came into force on 9 August 1990.
The Export Control Organisation's computer databases have been interrogated and a total of 2,973 licences were issued for the export of goods to Iraq between 9 August 1990 and 31 January 1998. Full details of these licences could be provided only at disproportionate cost.
488W
Licences issued for the export of goods to Iraq between 9 August 1990 and 31 January 1998 Year Number 9 August 1990 to 31 December 1990 5 1991 154 1992 418 1993 334 1994 635 1995 467 1996 349 1997 564 1 January 1998 to 31 January 1998 47 Between 1 January 1994 and 31 January 1998, 48 Open Individual Export Licences (OIELs) were issued authorising the export of protective clothing mainly for the protection of aid agency workers and journalists. This information should be considered in light of my answer to my hon. Friend the Member for Don Valley (Caroline Flint) of 30 October 1997, Official Report, columns 870–71. It would entail disproportionate costs to determine whether or not any such OIELs were issued between 9 August 1990 and 31 December 1993.
In addition, there are five Open General Export Licences (OGELs) under which specified goods may be exported to Iraq subject to the conditions of the licence: OGEL (Ships' stores: Aircraft stores); OGEL (Personal effects); OGEL (Documents); OGEL (Specified medical goods to the Red Cross); OGEL (Human remains). Copies of all of these licences are in the Library of the House. Formulated complex growth medium is not covered by OGEL (Specified medical goods to the Red Cross).
Of the licences issued between 9 August 1990 and 30 September 1996, 30 have been identified covering formulated complex growth media, and readily available details of these are as follows:
489W
Date of issue Quantity Approx. value of shipment/£ Stated end-use 31.05.91 102kg 4,000 World Health Organisation (WHO) cholera control project 31.10.91 130kg 4,600 WHO cholera control project 24.01.92 1,095kg 28,600 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 24.02.92 25kg 1,100 UNICEF 19.06.92 6.2kg 200 Red Cross water and sanitation project 30.06.92 285kg 12,100 WHO 31.07.92 620.5kg 20,000 WHO 30.09.92 40kg 1,300 WHO 28.06.93 30.5kg 1,100 Veterinary work in hospital laboratories 30.07.93 20kg 1,100 UNICEF nutrition 5 litres research project 08.02.94 51kg 2,300 UNICEF 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories
Date of issue Quantity Approx. value of shipment/£ Stated end-use 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 18.04.95 181.5kg 4,200 Cholera control in hospital laboratories 04.12.95 335kg 7,800 WHO 10.01.96 4kg 600 WHO 2 litres However, as details of all of the goods covered by individual applications are not recorded on the relevant database, it is possible that other licences covering formulated complex growth media might have been issued during this period. Any such other licences could be identified only by examination of the paper records of all licences issued since 9 August 1990, which would entail disproportionate cost.
Since 1 October 1996, the UK has issued nine licences covering the export of formulated complex growth media to Iraq, which is covered by the Import and Export (IMPEX) Mechanism established under UN Security Council resolution 1051, which came into force in October 1996. In each case, in accordance with our obligations under UN Security Council resolution 661, the Government confirmed that the applications were to export supplies strictly for medical purposes. The UN Sanctions Committee was notified, as was the UNSCOM-IAEA Joint Unit. The IMPEX Mechanism covers specified goods with the potential for use in the development and production of weapons of mass destruction and provides for monitoring of their use in Iraq by the UN Special Commission (UNSCOM).
For six of the nine licences referred to in the paragraph above the consignees were UN agencies. For the three other licences, the exports were specifically authorised by the UN Sanctions Committee under the "Oil for Food" programme based on UN Security Council resolution 986 and successor resolutions. The date of each licence, the quantity of formulated complex growth medium covered and the stated end-use are in the table.
490W
Licences issued since 1 October 1996 for the export of formulated complex growth media to Iraq. Date of issue Quantity Approx. value of shipment Stated end-use 12.02.97 5 litres £500 World Health Organisation (WHO) poliomyelitis diagnosis project 07.05.97 10kg £1,000 WHO tuberculosis 0.5 litre control project 21.05.97 10kg £750 WHO nutrition research project 21.07.971 1,670.7kg £54,000 Hospital laboratories under the UN "Oil for Food" Programme 09.10.97 27kg £1,000 UNICEF urban and semi-urban water project 14.10.97 14 litres $500 Hospital laboratories under the UN "Oil for Food" Programme 11.11.97 3 litres $50 International Atomic Energy Agency rinderpest surveillance project 28.01.98 40kg £1,000 WHO primary healthcare project 30.01.98 40kg $4,000 Hospital laboratories under the UN "Oil for Food" Programme 1This licence expired before the goods concerned were exported, and a new licence with the same coverage and for the same end-use was issued on 19.12.97.