§ Mrs. ClwydTo ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs how many current or former Indonesian police officers who received any form of training paid for by his Department served with the riot police, Sabhara unit of the Indonesian national police(a) before such training, (b) during such training and (c) after such training; if he will give the name of each such officer, the dates of his training and the dates of his service with the riot police. [31757]
§ Mr. HanleyAccording to the Indonesian national police, no officer who has received training support under the police project has served with the Sabhara unit.
§ Mrs. ClwydTo ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, pursuant to his answer of 3 March,Official Report, column 727, if he will name the Indonesian police officers who have been trained, for whatever length of time, under the police management training project since it began, in each case specifying the officer's rank and the date of commencement and of completion of the training. [31705]
§ Mr. HanleySince the national police management training project began in June 1990 we have provided UK training for the following:
609W
Name Rank Date training commenced Date training completed Study tours Mr. C.H.M. Waskito Colonel July 1990 July 1990 Mr. F. Sumampow Lieutenant Colonel July 1990 July 1990 Mr. H. Rasyid Colonel July 1990 July 1990 Mr. Soebariliyono Lieutenant Colonel July 1990 July 1990 Mr. Suryaningprang Lieutenant Colonel July 1990 July 1990 Mr. Y.Y. Laoli Lieutenant Colonel July 1990 July 1990 Mr. D. Rustadi Lieutenant Colonel July 1990 July 1990 Mr. M. Thonyib Captain July 1990 July 1990 Mr. N. Eko Captain July 1990 July 1990 Mr. Lihawa Brigadier General July 1990 July 1990 1991–92 Scholarships Mrs. Minton Mariaty Simanjuntak Major 13 September 1991 12th December 1991 Mr. Soekamid Major 1 October 1991 30th September 1992 Mr Yadi Ermlady Captain 1 October 1991 30th September 1992 Study tours Mr. G. Sumampow Lieutenant Colonel July 1991 July 1991 Mr. H. Rasyid Colonel July 1991 July 1991 Mr. Soebarilyono Lieutenant Colonel July 1991 July 1991 Mr. M. Suryaningprang Lieutenant Colonel July 1991 July 1991 Mr. Y.Y. Laoli Lieutenant Colonel July 1991 July 1991 Mr. D. Rustadi Lieutenant Colonel July 1991 July 1991 Mr. M. Thoyib Captain July 1991 July 1991 Mr. N. Eko Captain July 1991 July 1991 1991–92 Study tours Mr. Soekamid Major July 1991 July 1991 Mr. Y. Ermlady Captain July 1991 July 1991 1992–93 Scholarships Mr. Soekamid Major 1 October 1992 30th September 1993 Mr. Yadi Ermlady Captain 1 October 1992 30th September 1994 Ms Pengasihan Gaut Major 1 August 1992 30th November 1992 Mr. Adjie Rustam Ramdja Major 8 December 1992 7th April 1993 Mr. Pepe Tjhjana Lieutenant Colonel 8 December 1992 7th April 1993 Study tours Mr. C.H.M Waskito Colonel July 1992 July 1992 Mr. F. Sumampow Lieutenant Colonel July 1992 July 1992 Mr. H. Rasyid Colonel July 1992 July 1992 Mr. Soebariliyono Lieutenant Colonel July 1992 July 1992 Mr. Suryaningprang Lieutenant Colonel July 1992 July 1992 Mr. Y.Y. Laoli Lieutenant Colonel July 1992 July 1992 Mr. D. Rustadi Lieutenant Colonel July 1992 July 1992 Ms Hemawati Major July 1992 July 1992 Ms M. Simanjuntak Major July 1992 July 1992 Ms R.P. Gaut Major July 1992 July 1992 Mr. M. Thoyib Captain July 1992 July 1992 Mr. N. Eko Captain July 1992 July 1992 Mr. M.B. Hutagalung Major General July 1992 July 1992 Mr. R. Lihawa Brigadier General July 1992 July 1992 Mr. Karyoso Brigadier General July 1992 July 1992 1993–94 Scholarships Mr. Herman Rasyid Colonel 21 May 1993 20th June 1993 1994–95 Scholarships Mr. Wakin Major 1 July 1994 30th October 1994 Mr. Nicholas Eko Captain 1 August 1994 Mr. James Sitorus Lieutenant Colonel 1 August 1994 Mr. Fred Sumampow Lieutenant Colonel 13 April 1995 12th June 1995
§ Mrs. ClwydTo ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, pursuant to his answer of 3 March,Official Report, column 727, if he will name the Indonesian police officers who have undergone study 610W tours, for whatever length of time, to the United Kingdom since 1985, in each case specifying the officer's rank and the date of commencement and completion of the study tour. [21758]
611W
§ Mr. Hanley[holding reply 30 June 1995]: No study tours—visits of less than one month duration—took place between 1985 and 1990. Details of training since 1990 were given in my answer to the hon. Lady's further
Name Rank Date training commenced Date training completed 1985–86 Mr. Isnawan Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. Baruno Lieutenant Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. Yusar H. Lieutenant Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. Kresno Sukamso Lieutenant Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. Heru Tjipto Harsono Lieutenant Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. A. H. Sitorus Lieutenant Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. S. A. Supardi Lieutenant Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. Hamami Nata Lieutenant Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. Sebastian Koto Lieutenant Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. Astika Lieutenant Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. Ledwijk Lieutenant Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. Herman Hidayat Lieutenant Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. Adna Isa Lieutenant Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. J. D. Sitorus Lieutenant Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. Fred Sumampow Lieutenant Colonel 30 July 1985 18 December 1985 Mr. Chaerudin Lieutenant Colonel Dates not known Date not known 1986–87 Mr. Djumjatni G Colonel 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 Mr. Murni Tukiman Colonel 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 Mr. I. N. Yudana Colonel 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 Mr. Iksan Colonel 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 Mr. Asikin Nadikusumah Colonel 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 Mr. Soemitro Colonel 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 Mr. Dasuki Colonel 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 Mr. Pepe Tjahjana Lieutenant Colonel 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 Mr. Dadang Garnida Lieutenant Colonel 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 Mr. Deddy S K Lieutenant Colonel 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 Mr. Tjoek Sugiarso Major 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 Mr. Basjir A. Barmawai Major 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 Mr. Riswadi Herry S Major 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 1986–87 Scholarships Mr. M. Nian Sjafudin Major 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 Mr. Moch Saudi Major 6 October 1986 6 December 1986 Mr. Rachmat Lieutenant Colonel Date not known Date not known Mr. M. Hindarto Colonel April 1986 September 1986 1998–99 Mr. Ronny Lihawa Colonel October 1988 September 1989 Mr. Isnawan Colonel October 1988 September 1989
§ Mrs. ClwydTo ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs pursuant to his answer of 30 June,Official Report, column 802, what were the "relevant quarters" from which advice was sought on the police management training project in Indonesia; what advice was given on the issue of human rights; and at what Departmental level the project was approved. [33033]
§ Mr. HanleyI have nothing to add to the answer given by my hon. Friend the Member for Banbury (Mr. Baldry) on 30 June. Official advice to Ministers is given in confidence.
§ Mrs. ClwydTo ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs pursuant to his answer of 12 June,Official Report, column 381, if he will make a statement on the term "appropriate appraisals"; if he will define the term "full appraisal" in the letter of the Minister for Overseas Development of 20 January; and what is the difference between the two forms of appraisal. [33032]
612Wquestion concerning this project—No. 31705. The following longer-term training was undertaken during the period 1985–90.
§ Mr. HanleyIn a statement made on 17 June 1993 by the Under-Secretary for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, the House was informed of the future of the aid and trade provision, ATP, following a review of the programme. This included specific measures to improve the effectiveness of ATP. Appraisal procedures were brought into line with those applied to other bilateral aid projects to provide the same level of assurance concerning their soundness and sustainability.
The new procedures came into effect on 17 June 1993.
§ Mrs. ClwydTo ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs what steps he has taken to monitor the post-training careers of Indonesian police officers who have received any form of training paid for by his Department for the purpose of evaluating the effectiveness of the training in improving the officers respect for human rights. [31759]
613W
§ Mr. Hanley[holding reply 30 June 1995]: The project, including training, is monitored on an annual basis.