HC Deb 13 July 1987 vol 119 cc330-1W
Mr. Adley

asked the Secretary of State for Transport if, pursuant to his answer to the hon. Member for Christchurch of 6 July, Official Report, column 15, he will now list those formal investigations ordered under section 55 of the Merchant Shipping Act 1970 which he was including, in his answer of 29 June, Official Report, column 26, as being analogous with his stated policy on non-prosecution in the case of the Herald of Free Enterprise.

Mr. David Mitchell

In the past 10 years there have been 11 formal investigations held under the Merchant Shipping Acts, as follows:

Vessel
MFV Rotche/MFV Stroma II 1978 July 1977
MV Hero 1979 November 1977
MFV Boston Sea Ranger 1979 December 1977
MFV Do It Again 1979 January 1979
MV Kurdistan 1981 March 1979
MV Pool Fisher 1980 November 1979
MV Union Star and RNLB Solomon Browne 1983 December 1981
MV Grainville 1983 December 1981
MV European Galeway/MV Speedlink Vanguard 1983–84 December 1982
Marques 1985–86 June 1984
MV Herald of Free Enterprise 1987 March 1987

In the case of the Stroma II and Rotche, a prosecution was brought but the formal investigation was not held until after the criminal proceedings had been completed. It would riot he fair to the parties involved for me to comment on whether or not criminal offences were thought to have been committed in the remaining cases, but in none of them did the Department initiate any prosecution.