HC Deb 24 July 1984 vol 64 cc586-7W
Mr. Beith

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether, following the decision of the court in the appeal by Geoffrey Mycock who was convicted on the evidence of Dr. Alan Clift he will publish the report by Miss Christine Pereira of September 1978 relating to the evidence submitted in criminal cases by Dr. Alan Clift.

Mr. Hurd

No. This was a preliminary, internal report prepared by the director of the Aldermaston forensic science laboratory to the then controller of the Forensic Science Service for the purposes of considering whether Dr. Clift should be retired prematurely. It would be inappropriate to publish this document, which refers to police investigations and contains the names of suspects and victims. The conclusions of the report were fully summarised in paragraph 17 of the report by the Parliamentary Commissioner.

Mr. Beith

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether, following the decision of the court in the appeal by Geoffrey Mycock who was convicted on the evidence of Dr. Alan Clift, he will review his decision not to impose any financial penalty on Dr. Clift's early retirement pension.

Mr. Brittan

No.