HC Deb 05 August 1971 vol 822 cc366-7W
Dame Joan Vickers

asked the Minister of State for Defence whether he is now able to make a statement about the outcome of the investigations into the circumstances of the Plymouth to Fowey Race on the 18th June, 1971, during which two naval ratings lost their lives.

Mr. Kirk

The report of the board of inquiry and the remarks of the Commander in Chief and Flag Officer concerned have now been received and examined.

It is concluded that the conditions under which the race was organised and run, which were similar to those under which all the previous races have been managed since the event was instituted in 1955, were adequate for normal circumstances. However, on this occasion the weather, which was unpleasant but not considered to be dangerous, deteriorated once the race was well under way. The forecast reflected the trend of changing conditions and was consistent in predicting their deterioration but actual wind strengths exceeded the estimates and sea conditions became very difficult. By that time the fleet of 35 boats which had started the race had become widely scattered and could not be kept under tight control. Seven of the craft became casualties and it is regretted that two ratings sailing in a whaler which capsized were drowned.

The report praises the prompt action taken by H.M. Coastguard and the operational authorities concerned once it was realised that an emergency had occurred and the quick reaction and skill of the Service personnel who assisted with the rescue operations. The high standard of seamanship and leadership shown by all the boat coxswains is also mentioned.

In the light of this investigation a number of organisational and material improvements will be made with the object of improving safety standards in future years. No blame attaches to the Meterological Office, whose forecasts for the area were reasonably accurate.

I would like to reiterate the tribute which has already been paid to all the civilians who contributed so splendidly to the rescue efforts. I would also express again our sympathy with the parents and relatives of the two men who died.