HC Deb 11 May 1927 vol 206 cc392-3W
Mr. CADOGAN

asked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether he is aware that the captain of the steamer "Ninian" has been imprisoned in Venezuela, following upon an accident, to his ship which resulted in the death of a Venezuelan; and whether, with regard to the fact that the accident was beyond the control of this officer, he will make representations to the proper quarter that the severity of the punishment be mitigated?

Sir A. CHAMBERLAIN

The matter has been brought to my notice, and His Majesty's Minister at Caracas is following it closely. As regards Captain Brining's imprisonment, the facts are as follows: After investigation by the local authorities into the circumstances of the accident, the Judge ordered a criminal prosecution of Captain Brining. Under Venezuelan law, bail is not permissible in cases of homicide, but Captain Brining was allowed, as a, special privilege, to remain in the British Vice-Consul's house. This concession has now been withdrawn, and he has been put in prison. His imprisonment is, therefore, not the result of his trial, which has not yet taken place, but is due to, and in accordance with, the provisions of Venezuelan law in such cases. His Majesty's Minister at Caracas has satified himelf that the action taken by the Venezuelan authorities in this case has been in accordance with law, and there are at present no grounds for any protest. He is, however, taking such unofficial action as he properly can to assist Captain Brining, and to expedite a hearing of his case.