HC Deb 07 November 1916 vol 87 cc78-9W
Mr. W. THORNE

asked the President of the Board of Trade what was the reason for excluding the Press from the Food Prices Committee; whether the minutes of evidence are to be published and placed on public sale; whether it is the almost invariable rule when witnesses give evidence before Government Committees for a copy of their evidence to be sent to them to read over and correct; why was this procedure abandoned with respect to the inquiry conducted by this Committee; and whether all the witnesses have said is solely dependent on the veracity of the single reporter employed, and that no guarantee exists that the statements of a witness may not be presented for the Committee's final consideration in a light quite otherwise than when under examination?

Mr. RUNCIMAN

I understand that the Committee consider that by holding their meetings privately they have secured valuable evidence on many points which would probably not have been elicited at a public hearing. The Committee are of opinion that the complete evidence given should not be published in view of the confiden- tial character of much of it. I am informed that it has been the usual practice to submit to witnesses a copy of the report of their evidence, although, owing to special circumstances, there have been a few exceptions to this general practice.