§ Mr. McLeishTo ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will give for Highlands and Islands Enterprise and Scottish Enterprise and for each of the local enterprise companies the names of the chairman and board members, their occupations or professions and their allowances, salaries or other remuneration payable.
§ Mr. Stewart[holding answer 10 May 19931: The names, occupations and current salaries of the chairmen and board members of Scottish Enterprise and of Highlands and Islands Enterprise are as follows:
419W
Highlands and Islands Enterprise Members Occupation Salary from 1 April 1993 (£) Chairman (part-time) A. Fraser Morrison, CBE Chairman and Managing Director, Morrison Construction Group 26,762 Members (part-time) John A. D. Harrison, OBE Chairman, Johnston's of Elgin 7,030 Dr. James Hunter Journalist; 7,030 Adviser to the Crofters Union; Member, Board of Trustees, John Muir Trust Angus S. MacDonald, CBE Farmer; 7,030 Director, Grampian Television Valerie MacIver Chair, Highland Regional Council Education Committee; 7,030 Member, Ross and Cromarty District Council; Member, Cromarty Firth Port Authority John D. M. Robertson, CBE Chairman, Robertson Group of Companies; 7,030 Chairman, Orkney Health Board; Chairman, Highland Health Board Peter Timms, MBE Managing Director, Flexible Technology, Bute 7,030 John Angus Mackay Director, Gaelic Television Committee; 7,030 Member, Scottish Arts Council Chief Executive (ex-officio member) Iain A. Robertson 58,580 Chairmen and board members of the local enterprise companies are not appointed by my right hon. Friend. Their names are listed in their respective annual reports and accounts which are available from the local enterprise companies themselves. The contracts between Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise and the local enterprise companies in their respective areas prohibit the payment to local enterprise companies chairmen or board members of any remuneration from
420W
Occupation/ Profession Annual remuneration (£) ABERDEEN ROYAL HOSPITALS NHS TRUST Chairman: Mr. A. Bryan Broomfield Managing Director 19,285 Non-executive directors: Professor Graeme Catto University Professor 5,000 Professor Michael Meston University Professor 5,000 Mr. Harold Tocher Retired Banker 5,000 Dr. Fiona Lyle Retired General Practitioner 5,000 Mrs. Ann D. Scott Tax Partner 5,000 AYRSHIRE AND ARRAN COMMUNITY HEALTH CARE NHS TRUST Chairman: Mrs. Aileen K. Bates Former Nurse Teacher 17,145 Non-executive directors: Mr. Ian Allison Chartered Accountant 5,000 Mr. David Gall Retired Policeman 5,000 Mr. Robert Johnston Solicitor 5,000 Dr. Susan Kinnaird Auditor 5,000 Mr. W. Scott McConnell Retail Pharmacist 5,000 CAITHNESS AND SUTHERLAND NHS TRUST Chairman: Mr. George Bruce Former Company Manager 15,125 Non-executive directors: Mr. John Gunn Chartered Accountant 5,000 payments made by Scottish Enterprise or Highlands and Islands Enterprise; however, out-of-pocket expenses may be reimbursed.
§ Mr. McLeishTo ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will give for each of the hospital trusts the names of the board members, their occupations or professions and any allowances or remuneration payable.
§ Mr. Stewart[holding answer 10 May 1993]: The information requested is as follows:
421W
422W423W
Occupation/ Profession Annual remuneration (£) Rev. Alexander Murray Minister 5,000 Dr. Elizabeth MacKenzie Retired General Practitioner 5,000 Mr. John Rosie Technical Assistant 5,000 Ms Wilma Taylor Retired Nurse 5,000 DUNDEE TEACHING HOSPITALS NHS TRUST Chairman: Mr. J. Stuart Fair Solicitor 19,285 Non-executive directors: Mrs. Maureen Cane Retired University Lecturer 5,000 Mr. Gordon Lowden Chartered Accountant 5,000 Mr. Robert Lyon University Senior Lecturer 5,000 Mrs. Jacqueline Wood Housewife 5,000 Professor Heather Dick University Professor 5,000 GRAMPIAN HEALTH CARE NHS TRUST Chairman: Dr. Alexander J. Taylor Retired General Practitioner 19,285 Non-executive directors: Mr. Marcus Humphrey Farmer 5,000 Mr. Thomas Murison Managing Director 5,000 Mr. George Robb Company Director 5,000 Mrs. Joan Catto Solicitor 5,000 Mr. Hance Fullerton Chief Executive 5,000 MONKLANDS AND BELLSHILL NHS TRUST Chairman: Dr. George Bell Retired General Practitioner 19,285 Non-executive directors: Mrs. Ann Irvine Sales Consultant 5,000 Mr. Donald MacDonald Executive Director 5,000 Dr. Michael Moore University Reader 5,000 Mrs. Alison Morrison Veterinary Surgeon 5,000 Mr. William Huggins Retired Finance Director 5,000 MORAY HEALTH SERVICES NHS TRUST Chairman: Mr. James Snedden Retired Banker 17,145 Non-executive directors: Mrs. Marjory Adams Teacher 5,000 Mr. Russell Anderson Fanner 5,000 Mrs. Lydia King Retired Teacher 5,000 Mr. William Phillips Chartered Accountant 5,000 Mr. James Royan Master Butcher 5,000 NORTH AYRSHIRE AND ARRAN NHS TRUST Chairman: Mr. William Ritchie Retired Civil Engineer 19,285 Non-executive directors: Mrs. Angela Dunbar School Attendance Officer 5,000 Mrs. Kim Donald Company Secretary 5,000 Mr. James Grier Retired Banker 5,000 Mr. Alan Stewart Solicitor 5,000 Mr. Keith Tulloch Chartered Accountant 5,000 RAIGMORE HOSPITAL NHS TRUST Chairman: Mr. James Kyle Retired Surgeon 17,145 Non-executive directors: Mr. James Gray Retired Health Board Treasurer 5,000 Mrs. Flora Hunt Solicitor 5,000 Mr. Alexander Morrison Master Baker 5,000 Professor George McNicol Retired University Vice-Chancellor 5,000 Mrs. Judith Robertson Housewife 5,000 ROYAL ALEXANDRA HOSPITAL NHS TRUST Chairman: Mr. Tom Gibson former Hospice Director 17,145
424W425W
Occupation/Profession Annual remuneration (£) Non-executive directors: Mrs. Audrey Burns Housewife 5,000 Mr. Allan Durward Retired Chief Executive 5,000 Mrs. Marion Ford Housewife 5,000 Mr. Alec Macdonald Gaunt Retired Commandant, Erskine Hospital 5,000 Mr. George Murray Retired Locomotive Driver 5,000 ROYAL SCOTTISH NATIONAL HOSPITAL AND COMMUNITY NHS TRUST Chairman: Mr. Adrian D. Ward Solicitor 17,145 Non-executive directors: Mr. William Hughes Company Chairman 5,000 Ms Valerie Smart Chartered Accountant 5,000 Professor Averil Stewart College Professor 5,000 Mr. David Tarr Chief Scientific Engineer 5,000 Dr. Peter Williams Senior Engineer 5,000 SOUTH AYRSHIRE HOSPITALS NHS TRUST Chairman: Mr. J. Douglas Brown Retired Surgeon 17,145 Non-executive directors: Mr. William M. Mowatt Chartered Accountant 5,000 Mr. Harold J. Currie Business Consultant 5,000 Mr. Graeme McKinstry Solicitor 5,000 Mrs. Anne Wilson Housewife 5,000 Mrs. Dorothy McLellan Housewife 5,000 SOUTHERN GENERAL HOSPITAL NHS TRUST Chairman: Mr. Andrew Garland Partner, Construction Company 19,285 Non-executive directors: Mr. Robert McEwan Retired Director, Scottish Development Agency 5,000 Mrs. Ann Moore Solicitor 5,000 Mrs. Agnes Stewart Tax Adviser 5,000 Mr. Henry Tankel Retired Surgeon 5,000 Mrs. Susan Bell Company Director 5,000 STIRLING ROYAL INFIRMARY NHS TRUST Chairman: Mr. George B. McKelvie Retired Surgeon 17,145 Non-executive directors: Mrs. Agnes Bowie Company Director 5,000 Mr. Graham Houston Head of Industrial Society 5,000 Mrs. Doris Littlejohn President, Industrial Tribunals 5,000 Mr. Graeme Simmers Retired Company Chairman 5,000 Mrs. Anne Walker University Research Fellow 5,000 VICTORIA INFIRMAR NHS TRUST Chairman: Dr. John L. C. Dall Retired Physician 19,285 Non-executive directors: Dr. Robert Colville Retired General Practitioner 5,000 Mrs. Danielle Glasser Solicitor 5,000 Mrs. Lorna Howieson Pharmacist 5,000 Mrs. Alison Gilchrist Company Director 5,000 Mr. Desmond O'Brien Chartered Accountant 5,000 WEST LOTHIAN NHS TRUST Chairman: Mr. Robert S. Watt Chairman of Livingston Development Corporation 19,285 Non-executive directors: Mr. Thomas Bennie Retired Banker 5,000 Mr. Jack Cunningham Retired Trade Union Secretary 5,000 Mrs. Irene Douglas Company Accountant 5,000 Mr. Peter Johnston School Teacher 5,000 Mrs. Carole Stevenson Housewife 5,000
Occupation/Profession Annual remuneration (£) YORKHILL NHS TRUST Chairman: Mrs. Joan Cameron Housewife 19,285 Non-executive directors: Dr. John Davidson Retired Consultant Radiologist 5,000 Mrs. Margaret Hall Solicitor 5,000 Mr. Ronald Cleland Partner, Recruitment Consultancy 5,000 Mrs. Gwendoline Garner Field Worker, Action for Sick Children 5,000 Mrs. Sally Kuenssberg Children's Panel Training Organiser 5,000 Executive directors are appointed directly by trust boards, which also determine their salaries.
In addition to the remuneration payable, the chairmen and non-executive directors are entitled to claim travelling and subsistence allowances at rates set for members of public bodies.
426W
Occupation/ profession Annual remuneration (£) ARGYLL AND CLYDE HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Mr. R. R. Reid Farmer 17,700 Non-executive members: Mr. M. D. Jones Company Director 5,000 Mrs. E. S. Lander Company Director 5,000 Mrs. J. C. Le Roux Housewife 5,000 Dr. J. Moffat Retired Consultant Psychiatrist 5,000 Mrs. S. Nelson Primary School Teacher 5,000 Mr. C. H. Parker Company Director 5,000 Executive members: Mr. I. C. Smith General Manager — Dr. A. A. Reid Director of Public Health — AYRSHIRE AND ARRAN HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Mr. J. W. G. Donaldson Electrical Engineer 14,835 Non-executive members: Dr. K. G. Fegan General Medical Practitioner 5,000 Mr. J. H. Greene Solicitor 5,000 Miss M. W. Grosset Company Secretary 5,000 Miss K. A Paterson Retired Nurse 5,000 Mrs. E. Reid Health Carer 5,000 Mr. W. Young Company Director 5,000 Executive members: Mr. J. M. Eckford General Manager — Mr. N. R. Lammie Director of Finance — Mrs. M. Durie Director of Quality and Service Development/Chief Area Nursing Officer — Dr. A. D. W. Walker Director of Health Planning and Public Health — BORDERS HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Mr. D. A. G. Kilshaw Solicitor 11,960 Non-executive members: Rev. A. Bennett Minister 5,000 Miss M. Marshall Chartered Secretary 5,000 Mr. J. P. Metcalfe Retired Company Chairman 5,000 Dr. A. G. Paton Retired General Practitioner 5,000 Lady Sanderson Business Consultant 5,000 Mr. H. S. U. Steven NFU Secretary 5,000
§ Mr. McLeishTo ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will give for each of the health boards the names of the chairman and board members, their occupations or professions and their level of allowances or remuneration payable.
§ Mr. Stewart[holding answer 10 May 1993]: The information requested is as follows:
427W
428W429W
Occupation/profession Annual remuneration (£) Executive members: Mr. D. A. Peters General Manager — Dr. I. A. McDonald Director of Public Health — Mr. J. S. Wilson Director of Finance — Mrs. A. Weston Director of Quality Assurance/Chief Area Nursing Officer — DUMFRIES AND GALLOWAY HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Mr. J. A. McIntyre Farmer 11,960 Non-executive members: Mrs. V. M. I. Jardine, Paterson Housewife 5,000 Mr. H. S. McFadzean Farmer 5,000 Dr. J. R. C. Stubbs Retired Anaesthetist 5,000 Mrs. M. J. Thomson Former Member, South of Scotland Electricity Board 5,000 Mrs. J. D. Tulloch Company Director 5,000 Dr. A. P. D. Wilkinson General Practitioner 5,000 Executive members: Mr. D. J. Banks General Manager — Mr. D. McEachran Director of Finance — Mr. P. J. Kelly Director of Quality/Chief Area Nursing Officer — Mr. P. Milligan Director of Contracts and Planning — Dr. I. MacLean Director of Public Health — FIFE HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Mr. R. Baker Company Director 14,835 Non-executive members: Mrs. S. L. Aitken Housewife 5,000 Dr. A. C. A. Alexander General Practitioner 5,000 Mr. F. J. R. Craig Company Director 5,000 Mrs. M. Steedman Retired Headmistress 5,000 Mrs. C. Stenhouse Housewife 5,000 Mr. G. M. Thomson Chartered Accountant 5,000 Executive members: Dr. I. S. Jones Director of Public Health — Mr. M. D. Murray Director of Finance — Mrs. J. Edey Director of Strategic Planning and Contracts — FORTH VALLEY HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Mrs. J. I. D. Isbister Mental Welfare Commissioner 14,835 Non-executive members: Mr. E. T. M. Bell-Scott Solicitor 5,000 Mr. K. Harding Newsagent 5,000 Dr. G. B. Hastings Unit Director, Strathclyde University 5,000 Mr. P. A. Joynson Chartered Surveyor 5,000 Mrs. K. A. Smith Emergency Services Organiser, WRVS 5,000 Mr. C. S. R. Stroyan Solicitor 5,000 Executive members: Dr. D. C. Moir Director of Public Health — Mr. D. F. Hird Director of Finance — GRAMPIAN HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Dr. C. A. MacLeod Company Chairman 20,180 Non-executive members: Mr. J. K. O. Arbuthnott Estate Owner/Manager 5,000 Mrs. C. A. Ferguson Housewife/Farmer 5,000 Mr. G. McLellan Senior Executive 5,000 Professor D. Ogston University Professor 5,000 Mrs. M. E. L. Park Solicitor 5,000 Mrs. J. G. A. Wisely Housewife 5,000 Executive members: Mr. F. Hartnett General Manager —
430W431W
Occupation/profession Annual remuneration (£) Mr. A. J. Cumming Director of Finance — Dr. H. R. M. Wilson Director of Contracts — Ms H. Blumer Director of Planning — Dr. G. Paterson Director of Public Health — GREATER GLASGOW HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Mr. W. S. Fyfe Company Chairman 25,140 Non-executive members: Rev. R. D. M. Campbell Minister 5,000 Mr. P. W. Hoist Company Director 5,000 Professor R. M. Mackie University Professor 5,000 Mr. W. C. McCreath Solicitor 5,000 Mrs. J. Mackenzie Housewife 5,000 Mr. P. H. L. I. Runciman Retired Company Chairman 5,000 Mr. A. Scobbie Managing Director 5,000 Executive members: Mr. L. E. Peterken General Manager — Dr. G. D. Forwell Director of Public Health — Mr. C. M. Gordon Director of Finance — Mr. T. A. Divers Director of Planning and Contracts — HIGHLAND HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Mr. J. D. M. Robertson Company Chairman 14,835 Non-executive members: Mr. J. G. Ligertwood Retired Bank Manager 5,000 Dr. D. J. MacDonald Retired General Practitioner 5,000 Mr. D. J. Mackay Chief Executive 5,000 Mrs. A. MacPherson Farm Business Partner 5,000 Mr. C. Neilson Retail Businessman 5,000 Mrs. C. Thomson Company Director 5,000 Executive members: Mr. R. R. W. Stewart General Manager — Dr. G. V. Stone Director of Public Health — Mr. M. Iredale Director of Finance — Mr. D. T. Wright Director of Quality Assurance/Chief Area Nursing Officer — LANARKSHIRE HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Mr. I. L. Livingstone Solicitor 17,700 Non-executive members: Dr. W. Criggie General Practitioner 5,000 Mrs. A. S. Hinshalwood Housewife 5,000 Mrs. M. Melvin Teacher 5,000 Mr. D. A. Millar Business Consultant 5,000 Mr. J. P. Robinson Retired Colliery Official 5,000 Mr. J. Thomson Director, Voluntary Organisation 5,000 Executive members: Mr. F. Clark General Manager — Dr. J. B. P. Ferguson Director of Public Health — Mr. M. Docherty Director of Finance — Mr. B. Gill Director of Corporate Planning and Estates — Miss E. Hastings Director of Quality Assurance/Chief Area Nursing Officer — LOTHIAN HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Dr. J. W. Baynham Company Director 22,660 Non-executive members: Professor R. C. B. Aitken University Professor 5,000 Mrs. G. Barton Housewife 5,000 Mr. J. A. Campbell Chartered Surveyor 5,000 Mr. R. Findlay Chief Executive, Radio Forth 5,000 Mrs. M. B. M. Knox Housewife 5,000 Mr. G. S. Millar Community Pharmacist 5,000
432W433W
Occupation/profession Annual remuneration (£) Executive members: Mr. J. Lusby General Manager — Dr. H. Zealley Director of Public Health — Mr. P. Wilson Director of Operations — Dr. L. Burley Director of Planning and Development — ORKNEY HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Mr. J. Leslie Pharmacist 7,200 Non-executive members: Mr. J. Flett Solicitor 2,000 Mr. E. M. Gibson Retired Assistant Headteacher 2,000 Captain M. Gunn Ships Master 2,000 Mrs. E. B. Kerr Housewife 2,000 Mr. J. Rendall Sub-Postmaster/Postman 2,000 Dr. J. S. Walker General Practitioner 2,000 Executive members: Mr. R. Allan Director of Finance — SHETLAND HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Mrs. F. B. Grains Housewife 7,200 Non-executive members: Mrs. M. U. Colligan Retired Teacher 2,000 Squadron Leader B. P. Gregson Local Government Officer 2,000 Dr. M. D. Hunter General Practitioner 2,000 Mr. R. L. Johnson Retired Businessman 2,000 Mrs. T. A. Leslie Teaching Auxiliary 2,000 Mr. J. Telford Chartered Accountant 2,000 Executive members: Mr. B. Atherton General Manager — Dr. D. Cox Director of Public Health — Mr. D. P. P. Eva Director of Finance — Mrs. M. Henderson Director of Contracts and Standards/ Chief Area Nursing Officer — TAYSIDE HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Mr. J. C. MacFarlane Retired Company Director 20,180 Non-executive members: Rev. K. Campbell Minister 5,000 Mr. D. W. M. Davidson Pharmacist 5,000 Mrs. V. Joiner Company Director 5,000 Mr. H. C. Nicoll Retired Local Government Officer 5,000 Professor R. E. Olver University Professor 5,000 Mr. I. Sandison Retired Company Director 5,000 Executive members: Dr. R. C. Graham General Manager — Dr. L. Cameron Director of Public Health — Mr. J. R. Hudson Director of Finance — Miss E. Edwards Chief Area Nursing officer/Director of Quality — WESTERN ISLES HEALTH BOARD Chairman: Mr. A. Matheson Pharmacist 7,200 Non-executive members: Dr. S. M. Brydon General Practitioner 2,000 Mr. J. A. Harrison Deputy Head Teacher 2,000 Mr. A. W. Hay Retired Sales Director 2,000 Mrs. C. R. MacAskill Housewife 2,000 Mrs. F. M. T. MacDonald Solicitor 2,000 Mr. M. MacLennan Building Society Manager 2,000 Executive members: Mr. G. Stobbs Director of Finance and Contracts — Executive members are employees of health boards and receive no additional remuneration for board membership. In addition to the remuneration indicated above, non-executive members are entitled to claim travelling and subsistence allowances at rates set for members of public bodies.
§ Mr. McLeishTo ask the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will list(a) the public bodies for which he is responsible, (b) their overall expenditure in 1992–93 for the most recent year for which figures are available, (c) the total number of people appointed to these bodies, (d) the number of males and females and (e) the total sum paid in allowances or salaries or other types of remuneration.
§ Mr. Lang[holding answer 10 May 1993]: I refer the hon. Member to the Cabinet Office publication "Public Bodies 1992" which was published on 29 January 1993 and a copy of which is available in the Library. This publication includes information on expenditure, membership and remuneration for the bodies for which I am responsible.