HL Deb 13 June 1989 vol 508 cc1410-2WA
Lord Brougham and Vaux

asked Her Majesty's Government:

What was the outcome of the European Communities Environment Council held in Luxembourg on 8th-9th June.

The Earl of Caithness

I represented the United Kingdom at this meeting.

I am delighted to report that, after exhaustive negotiations in which the UK played a leading role, the council agreed a directive on the second stage of exhaust emission standards for small cars. This now produces clear guidelines for the motor industry to follow in planning its future car production.

The agreement contains strict standards requiring under present technology three-way catalysts to be introduced on 1st July 1992 for new models and on 31st December 1992 for all new registrations. These are tough targets and the challenge they present to industry should not be underestimated. Nevertheless we believe them to be attainable. They are greatly to the advantage of the European environment, but do not control all the emissions from cars that cause concern. Thus, at UK insistence the Commission has undertaken to come forward with proposals to reduce these, not least of which is carbon dioxide, the most important greenhouse gas. The present agreement does not limit the emission of this gas and if anything will tend to increase it.

The unity of the market will be protected by an article in the directive which circumscribes the fiscal incentives that can be introduced by member states and requires all proposed incentives to be notified to the Commission.

As the House knows, the UK urged an indefinite ban on the import of harp and hooded seal pup skins and their products in 1985, when EC Directive 23/129 was extended for four years. Now I am delighted to announce that the council has unanimously agreed that the directive should be extended indefinitely. This is a significant step towards ensuring the conservation of these species.

The Community will support the case for listing the African Elephant on Appendix I of the Convention on Trade in Endangered Species, but of course recognises the need to listen to the arguments from all sides on the best long-term measures to protect this species. Meanwhile, as a precautionary measure I am also pleased to report that the council strongly supported the UK proposal for an immediate ban on the import into the Community of raw and worked ivory. The Commission will now bring forward proposals to impose a ban throughout the Community. Member states were invited to take their own action in advance of these proposals, and we have immediately imposed a ban on imports of ivory into the UK.

The council adopted a Resolution on the greenhouse effect which recognises the importance of the issue and the importance of the Community and all member states contributing fully to the wider international efforts to improve the understanding of climate change and develop policy responses to it.

I am pleased to report that agreement was reached on a directive requiring the up-grading of existing municipal waste incinerators according to specific timetables. The council also adopted a directive setting standards for new municipal waste incineration plants, following the agreement which was reached on 2nd March.

The council agreed an amendment to Directive 80/779 on air pollution from smoke and sulphur dioxide. The amendment concerns short-term methods of measurement which do not affect the UK. It also provides for a general review of the directive in which we shall be closely involved.

Agreement was reached on a directive which establishes a regulatory structure for laboratory and industrial processes working with genetically modified micro-organisms within containment. The directive lays down certain procedures for the notification of work and standards to be followed to protect human and environmental safety, which procedures are broadly compatible with existing domestic safety arrangements. The council voted unanimously to change the legal base from Article 100A to Article 130S, recognising that the predominant objective of the directive is one of environmental protection.

The council adopted a Directive leading to the elimination of pollution caused by wastes from the titanium dioxide industry and agreed unanimously that the legal base should be Article 130S.

A proposal to introduce controls over discharges of four dangerous substances of water was also discussed.

The Commission presented progress reports on a proposal concerning the protection of waters against pollution by nitrates and on a proposal concerning the protection of natural and semi-natural habitats and of wild fauna and flora.