HC Deb 19 December 1989 vol 164 cc179-89W
Mr. Simon Coombs

To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he will publish in theOfficial Report tables showing, for the latest years now available, identifiable general Government expenditure by function in England, Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland and the United Kingdom expressed (a) in cash terms, (b) as a percentage of United Kingdom total identifiable general Government expenditure, (c) as an amount per capita, and (d) as an amount per capita expressed as an index, United Kingdom identifiable general Government expenditure = 100.

Mr. Norman Lamont

Most public expenditure is planned on a national basis and there is no geographical disaggregation apart from expenditure which is the responsibility of the territorial Departments. However, in order to provide a more comprehensive breakdown of public expenditure within the four countries of the United Kingdom an additional analysis, covering outturn years, is carried out each year. This analysis allocates, where possible, expenditure to England, Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland and therefore includes within the territories a wider coverage of expenditure than that for which the Secretaries of State for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland are directly responsible.

In previous years this analysis has covered expenditure included within the planning total. Since the new planning total (announced in Cm. 441), on which outturn and plans for future years were published in the Autumn Statement (Cm. 879), includes central Government support for local authorities rather than local authority expenditure, the basis of the territorial analysis has been changed this year to cover general Government expenditure. The analysis thus covers central Government's own expenditure, finance for public corporations, and local authorities' expenditure, as it has in the past. Public corporations' market and overseas borrowing is, however, excluded.

The analysis divides expenditure into "identifiable" and "non-identifiable" expenditure. The term "identifiable expenditure" refers to expenditure that can be identified from official records as having been incurred for the benefit of people in a particular country. The coverage of identifiable expenditure has been expanded since last year's exercise to include grants, subsidies and net lending to those public corporations, mainly dealing with housing and development, where allocation between territories is possible on a consistent basis. Total identifiable expenditure accounts for around three quarters of general Government expenditure. The remainder, unidentifiable expenditure, covers mainly expenditure deemed to have been incurred on behalf of the United Kingdom as a whole, for example, defence, overseas aid and other overseas services. The coverage of identifiable expenditure is largely unaffected by the change of basis to general Government expenditure.

Tables 1 to 5 show figures for identifiable general Government expenditure according to main function in England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland in the years 1984–85 to 1988–89. The tables show identifiable general Government expenditure in each territory in total and on a per capita basis. The per capita figures are based on mid-year population estimates. Figures for earlier years are not available on a totally consistent basis with those given in these tables.

Table 6 compares, for the latest year, 1988–89, expenditure by function in the Scottish, Welsh and Northern Ireland programmes with the total identifiable expenditure in the respective countries. It shows that identifiable expenditure has a wider coverage than expenditure within the responsibilities of the Secretaries of State for Scotland and Wales; in the case of Northern Ireland it has a slightly wider coverage than the Northern Ireland programme. The table also shows, for 1988–89, unidentifiable expenditure where this can be allocated to function.

In some cases, expenditure which cannot be separately identified for England, Scotland or Wales can be allocated to Great Britain rather than the United Kingdom; for example, the majority of the finance provided for expenditure by the nationalised industries can be allocated to Great Britain. Tables 7a and 7b compare Northern Ireland allocated expenditure with that allocated to Great Britain over the five-year period.

The extent to which expenditure can be identified may vary from year to year and between countries. The coverage of particular functions can also vary between countries; for example, in Northern Ireland, expenditure on arts and libraries is contained in the education category.

The terms and definitions used for this analysis are the same as those used for the recent Autumn Statement (Cm. 879) but the figures are based on less up-to-date outturn information.

Table 1a Identifiable general government expenditure 1984–85
£ million
As a percentage of United Kingdom indentifiable expenditure
England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland United Kingdom England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland
Agriculture, fisheries, food and forestry 631.5 234.1 103.1 159.7 1,128.4 56.0 20.7 9.1 14.2
Trade, industry, energy and employment 3,290.6 739.8 385.4 331.4 4,747.2 69.3 15.6 8.1 7.0
Roads and transport 3,734.0 503.8 262.8 100.7 4,601.3 81.2 10.9 5.7 2.2
Housing 3,273.5 665.9 143.8 336.4 4,419.6 74.1 15.1 3.3 7.6
Other environmental services 3,573.5 508.6 270.2 184.2 4,536.5 78.8 11.2 6.0 4.1
Law, order and protective services 4,113.8 508.1 218.2 433.3 5,273.4 78.0 9.6 4.1 8.2
Education and science 13,489.1 2,019.4 840.6 609.8 16,958.9 79.5 11.9 5.0 3.6
Arts and Libraries 551.5 69.1 28.9 0.0 649.5 84.9 10.6 4.4 0.0
Health and personal social services 15,732.9 2,180.3 985.4 665.6 19,564.2 80.4 11.1 5.0 3.4
Social security 32,484.8 3,673.3 2,085.3 1,202.0 39,445.4 82.4 9.3 5.3 3.0
Miscellaneous1 1,084.9 232.7 108.2 55.9 1,481.7 73.2 15.7 7.3 3.8
Total 81,960.1 11,335.1 5,431.9 4,079.0 102,806.1 79.7 11.0 5.3 4.0

Table 1b Identifiable general government expenditure per head 1984–85
£ per head
Index (United Kingdom identifiable expenditure = 100)
England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland United Kingdom England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland
Agriculture, fisheries, food and forestry 13.4 45.5 36.7 103.0 20.0 67.3 227.6 183.8 515.4
Trade, industry, energy and employment 70.1 143.8 137.3 213.8 84.1 83.3 171.0 163.3 254.2
Roads and transport 79.5 97.9 93.6 65.0 81.5 97.6 120.1 114.9 79.7
Housing 69.7 129.4 51.2 217.0 78.3 89.1 165.3 65.4 277.2
Other environmental services 76.1 98.8 96.3 118.8 80.3 94.7 123.0 119.8 147.9
Law, order and protective services 87.6 98.7 77.7 279.5 93.4 93.8 105.7 83.2 299.2
Education and science 287.3 392.4 299.4 393.3 300.4 95.6 130.7 99.7 130.9
Arts and Libraries 11.7 13.4 10.3 0.0 11.5 102.1 116.7 89.5 0.0
Health and presonal social services 335.1 423.7 351.0 429.3 346.5 96.7 122.3 101.3 123.9
Social security 691.8 713.9 742.8 775.3 698.6 99.0 102.2 106.3 111.0
Miscellaneous1 23.1 45.2 38.5 36.1 26.2 88.0 172.3 146.9 137.4
Total 1,745.5 2,202.8 1,935.0 2,630.9 1,820.9 95.9 121.0 106.3 144.5
1 Includes expenditure associated with the general maintenance of government, such as tax collection and population registration.

Table 2a Identifiable general government expenditure 1985–86
£ million
As a percentage of United Kingdom identifiable expenditure
England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland United Kingdom England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland
Agriculture, fisheries, food and forestry 632.7 254.2 109.3 153.8 1,150.0 55.0 22.1 9.5 13.4
Trade, industry, energy and employment 3,484.2 683.3 346.4 375.4 4,889.3 71.3 14.0 7.1 7.7
Roads and transport 3,486.3 539.5 268.4 101.3 4,395.5 79.3 12.3 6.1 2.3
Housing 2,969.8 620.1 135.3 345.5 4,070.7 73.0 15.2 3.3 8.5
Other environmental services 3,663.1 501.2 292.2 196.5 4,653.0 78.7 10.8 6.3 4.2
Law, order and protective services 4,191.9 531.4 228.4 473.2 5,424.9 77.3 9.8 4.2 8.7
Education and science 14,013.3 2,101.8 854.8 637.4 17,607.3 79.6 11.9 4.9 3.6
Arts and libraries 581.8 75.1 31.6 0.0 688.5 84.5 10.9 4.6 0.0
Health and personal social services 16,588.1 2,315.3 1,051.0 697.8 20,652.2 80.3 11.2 5.1 3.4
Social security 35,258.0 4,072.1 2,245.1 1,310.1 42,885.3 82.2 9.5 5.2 3.1
Miscellaneous1 1,186.9 237.5 108.9 62.1 1,595.4 74.4 14.9 6.8 3.9
Total 86,056.1 11,931.5 5,671.4 4,353.1 108,012.1 79.7 11.0 5.3 4.0

Table 2b Identifiable general government expenditure per head 1985–86
£ per head
Index (United Kingdom identifiable expenditure = 100)
England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland United Kingdom England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland
Agriculture, fisheries, food and forestry 13.4 49.5 38.9 98.7 20.3 66.1 243.6 191.4 486.1
Trade, industry, energy and employment 74.0 133.0 123.2 241.0 86.4 85.6 154.0 142.7 279.1
Roads and transport 74.0 105.0 95.5 65.0 77.6 95.3 135.3 123.0 83.8
Housing 63.0 120.7 48.1 221.8 71.9 87.7 167.9 66.9 308.5
Other environmental services 77.8 97.6 103.9 126.1 82.2 94.6 118.7 126.4 153.5
Law, order and protective services 89.0 103.5 81.2 303.8 95.8 92.9 108.0 84.8 317.0
Education and science 297.4 409.2 304.0 409.2 311.0 95.6 131.6 97.8 131.6
Arts and libraries 12.3 14.6 11.2 0.0 12.2 101.6 120.2 92.4 0.0
Health and personal social services 352.1 450.8 373.8 447.9 364.8 96.5 123.6 102.5 122.8
Social security 748.4 792.8 798.5 841.0 757.5 98.8 104.7 105.4 111.0
Miscellaneous1 25.2 46.2 38.7 39.9 28.2 89.4 164.1 137.4 141.5
Total 1,826.6 2,322.9 2,017.0 2,794.4 1,907.7 95.7 121.8 105.7 146.5
1 Includes expenditure associated with the general maintenance of government, such as tax collection and population registration.

Table 3a Identifiable general government expenditure 1984–85
£ million
As a percentage of United Kingdom identifiable expenditure
England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland United Kingdom England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland
Agriculture, fisheries, food and forestry 604.0 231.2 118.0 159.4 1,112.6 54.3 20.8 10.6 14.3
Trade, industry, energy and employment 3,897.6 801.4 433.3 387.7 5,520.0 70.6 14.5 7.8 7.0
Roads and transport 3,639.6 575.5 292.7 105.0 4,612.8 78.9 12.5 6.3 2.3
Housing 2,863.5 630.2 177.8 334.7 4,006.2 71.5 15.7 4.4 8.4
Other environmental services 3,846.5 546.7 330.4 209.6 4,933.2 78.0 11.1 6.7 4.2
Law, order and protective services 4,592.0 580.7 247.4 520.8 5,940.9 77.3 9.8 4.2 8.8
Education and science 15,298.3 2,248.5 942.5 730.6 19,219.9 79.6 11.7 4.9 3.8
Arts and Libraries 619.1 81.9 33.6 0.0 734.6 84.3 11.1 4.6 0.0
Health and personal social services 17,861.3 2,444.6 1.131.4 748.7 22,186.0 80.5 11.0 5.1 3.4
Social security 37,937.6 4,356.6 2,440.5 1,423.2 46,157.9 82.2 9.4 5.3 3.1
Miscellaneous1 1,332.5 270.6 120.8 70.4 1,794.3 74.3 15.1 6.7 3.9
Total 92,492.0 12,7679 6,268.4 4,690.1 116,218.4 79.6 11.0 5.4 4.0

Table 3b Identifiable general government expenditure per head 1986–87
£ per head
Index (United Kingdom identifiable expenditure = 100)
England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland United Kingdom England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland
Agriculture, fisheries, food and forestry 12.8 45.1 41.8 101.7 19.6 65.2 230.3 213.4 519.0
Trade, industry, energy and employment 82.5 156.5 153.6 247.4 97.2 84.8 160.9 157.9 254.5
Roads and transport 77.0 112.4 103.8 67.0 81.3 94.8 138.3 127.7 82.5
Housing 60.6 123.1 63.0 213.6 70.6 85.9 174.4 89.3 302.7
Other environmental services 81.4 106.8 117.1 133.8 86.9 93.7 122.8 134.8 153.9
Law, order and protective services 97.2 113.4 87.7 332.4 104.7 92.8 108.3 83.8 317.6
Education and science 323.7 439.1 334.1 466.3 338.6 95.6 129.7 98.7 137.7
Arts and Libraries 13.1 16.0 11.9 0.0 12.9 101.2 123.6 92.0 0.0
Health and personal social services 378.0 477.4 401.1 477.9 390.9 96.7 122.1 102.6 122.3
Social security 802.8 850.7 865.1 908.3 813.2 98.7 104.6 106.4 111.7
Miscellaneous1 28.2 52.8 42.8 44.9 31.6 89.2 167.2 135.5 142.1
Total 1,957.3 2,493.2 2,222.0 2,993.4 2,047.4 95.6 121.8 108.5 146.2
1 Includes expenditure associated with the general maintenance of government, such as tax collection and population registration.

Table 4a Identifiable general government expenditure 1987–88
£ million
As a percentage of United Kingdom identifiable expenditure
England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland United Kingdom England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland
Agriculture, fisheries, food and forestry 639.8 222.2 91.0 157.8 1,110.8 57.6 20.0 8.2 14.2
Trade, industry, energy and employment 3,699.8 713.8 415.0 369.2 5,197.8 71.2 13.7 8.0 7.1
Roads and transport 3,820.4 590.4 337.0 108.6 4,856.4 78.7 12.2 6.9 2.2
Housing 2,797.4 715.7 213.9 336.6 4,063.6 68.8 17.6 5.3 8.3
Other environmental services 3,751.8 587.3 356.8 229.6 4,925.5 76.2 11.9 7.2 4.7
Law, order and protective services 5,158.7 649.8 275.7 591.7 6,675.9 77.3 9.7 4.1 8.9
Education and science 16,644.0 2,444.8 1,046.4 789.1 20,924.3 79.5 11.7 5.0 3.8
Arts and Libraries 674.1 86.3 37.2 0.0 797.6 84.5 10.8 4.7 0.0
Health and personal social services 19,657.5 2,666.2 1,256.4 810.1 24,390.2 80.6 10.9 5.2 3.3
Social security 39,364.1 4,654.0 2,547.1 1,504.1 48,069.3 81.9 9.7 5.3 3.1
Miscellaneous1 1,524.7 296.0 130.7 72.2 2,023.6 75.3 14.6 6.5 3.6
Total 97,732.3 13,626.5 6,702.2 4,969.0 123,035.0 79.4 11.1 5.5 4.0

Table 4b Identifiable general government expenditure 1987–88
£ per head
Index (United Kingdom identifiable expenditure = 100)
England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland United Kingdom England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland
Agriculture, fisheries, food and forestry 13.5 43.4 32.1 100.2 19.5 69.2 222.3 164.4 513.5
Trade, industry, energy and employment 78.0 139.4 146.3 234.4 91.3 85.5 152.6 160.3 256.7
Roads and transport 80.6 115.3 118.8 68.9 85.3 94.5 135.1 139.3 80.8
Housing 59.0 139.7 75.4 213.7 71.4 82.7 195.8 105.7 299.4
Other environmental services 79.1 114.7 125.8 145.8 86.5 91.5 132.5 145.4 168.5
Law, order and protective services 108.8 126.9 97.2 375.7 117.3 92.8 108.2 82.9 320.4
Education and science 351.1 477.3 368.9 501.0 367.5 95.5 129.9 100.4 136.3
Arts and Libraries 14.2 16.8 13.1 0.0 14.0 101.5 120.3 93.6 0.0
Health and personal social services 414.7 520.5 443.0 514.3 428.4 96.8 121.5 103.4 120.0
Social security 830.3 908.6 898.1 954.9 844.4 98.3 107.6 106.4 113.1
Miscellaneous1 32.2 57.8 46.1 45.8 35.5 90.5 162.6 129.6 129.0
Total 2,061.6 2,660.3 2,364.9 3,154.7 2,161.2 95.4 123.1 109.4 146.0
1 Includes expenditure associated with the general maintenance of government, such as tax collection and population registration.

Table 5a Identifiable general government expenditure 1988–89
£ million
As a percentage of United Kingdom identifiable expenditure
England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland United Kingdom England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland
Agriculture, fisheries, food and forestry 786.4 254.0 106.5 171.4 1,318.3 59.7 19.3 8.1 13.0
Trade, industry, energy and employment 3,923.3 687.2 416.0 1786.2 5,812.7 67.5 11.8 7.2 13.5
Roads and transport 3,922.6 616.7 342.7 110.9 4,992.9 78.6 12.4 6.9 2.2
Housing 1,982.8 664.1 172.1 335.2 3,154.2 62.9 21.1 5.5 10.6
Other environmental services 4,050.2 662.3 364.3 260.2 5,337.0 75.9 12.4 6.8 4.9
Law, order and protective services 5,744.9 719.5 309.2 639.7 7,413.3 77.5 9.7 4.2 8.6
Education and science 17,930.4 2,660.4 1,116.3 851.7 22,558.8 79.5 11.8 4.9 3.8
Arts and Libraries 794.6 90.2 42.0 0.0 926.8 85.7 9.7 4.5 0.0
Health and personal social services 21,768.9 2,981.5 1,395.5 882.8 27,028.7 80.5 11.0 5.2 3.3
Social security 40,111.3 4,641.1 2,701.8 1,599.7 49,053.9 81.8 9.5 5.5 3.3
Miscellaneous2 1,698.5 313.9 143.4 83.9 2,239.7 75.8 14.0 6.4 3.7
Total 102,713.9 14,290.9 7,109.8 5,721.7 129,836.3 79.1 11.0 5.5 4.4

Table 5b Identifiable public expenditure per head 1988–89
£ per head
Index (United Kingdom identifiable expenditure = 100)
England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland United Kingdom England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland
Agriculture, fisheries, food and forestry 16.5 49.9 37.3 108.6 23.1 71.6 215.8 161.4 470.2
Trade, industry, energy and employment 82.5 134.9 145.6 1498.2 101.9 81.0 132.4 142.9 489.1
Roads and transport 82.5 121.1 120.0 70.3 87.5 94.3 138.4 137.1 80.3
Housing 41.7 130.4 60.2 212.4 55.3 75.5 235.9 109.0 384.3
Other environmental services 85.2 130.0 127.5 164.9 93.5 91.1 139.0 136.3 176.3
Law, order and protective services 120.9 141.2 108.2 405.4 129.9 93.0 108.7 83.3 312.1
Education and science 377.2 522.3 390.7 539.7 395.3 95.4 132.1 98.8 136.5
Arts and Libraries 16.7 17.7 14.7 0.0 16.2 102.9 109.0 90.5 0.0
Health and personal social services 457.9 585.3 488.4 559.4 473.6 96.7 123.6 103.1 118.1
Social security 843.8 911.1 945.7 1,013.8 859.6 98.2 106.0 110.0 117.9
Miscellaneous2 35.7 61.6 50.2 53.2 39.2 91.0 157.0 127.9 135.5
Total 2,160.7 2,805.4 2,488.6 3,625.9 2,275.2 95.0 123.3 109.4 159.4
1 Includes £390 million (£247 per head) for costs associated with the privatisation of Short Brothers PLC.
2 Includes expenditure associated with the general maintenance of government, such as tax collection and population registration.

Table 6: General government expenditure1 analysed by territorial area and function 1988–89
£ million
Identifiable expenditure
England Scotland (Total) Programme 152 Scotland other Wales (Total) Programme 162 Wales other Northern Ireland (Total) Programme 172 Northern Ireland other Total Non-Identified United Kingdom
Defence 18,974.4 18,974.4
Overseas services 2,268.9 2,268.9
Agriculture, fisheries, food and forestry 786.4 254.0 199.1 54.9 106.3 83.9 22.6 171.4 169.9 1.5 1,318.3 882.1 2,200.4
Trade, industry, energy and employment 3,923.3 687.2 266.2 421.0 416.0 186.1 229.9 3786.2 3786.2 5,812.7 2,551.1 8,364.1
Roads and transport 3,922.6 616.7 615.7 1.0 342.7 342.7 110.9 110.9 4,992.9 877.0 5,869.9
Housing 1,982.8 664.1 664.1 172.1 172.1 335.2 335.2 3,154.2 16.2 3,170.4
Other environmental services 4,050.2 662.3 656.5 5.8 364.3 359.2 5.1 260.2 260.2 5,337.0 727.6 6,064.6
Law, order and protective services 5344.9 719.5 692.7 26.8 309.2 309.2 639.7 606.8 32.9 7,413.3 1,372.8 8,786.1
Education and science4 17,930.4 2,660.4 2,318.0 342.4 1,116.3 946.4 169.9 851.7 849.5 2.2 22,558.8 133.3 22,692.1
Arts and libraries4 794.6 90.2 90.2 42.0 42.0 4 4 926.8 179.4 1,106.2
Health and personal social services 21,768.9 2,981.5 2,981.5 1,395.5 1,395.5 882.8 882.8 27,028.7 -32.8 26,995.9
Social security 40,111.3 4,641.1 4,641.1 2,701.8 2,701.8 1,599.7 1,587.9 11.8 49,053.9 798.9 49,852.8
Miscellaneous5 1,698.5 313.9 116.3 197.6 143.4 42.5 100.9 83.9 47.6 36.3 2,239.7 3,031.3 5,271.0
Total expenditure 102,713.9 14,290.9 8,600.3 5,690.6 7,109.8 3,570.4 3,539.4 5,721.7 5,637.0 84.7 129,836.3 31,780.5 161,616.8
1 Items included in general government expenditure but not included within total expenditure on programmes (privatisiation proceeds, general government debt interest and accounting adjustments) are treated as unidentified expenditure ad not allocated to territories.
2 Programmes 15, 16 and 17 relate to expenditure programmes in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland covered by the respective chapters of the 1989 public expenditure White Paper (Cm. 616–618).
3 Includes £390 million for costs associated with the privatisation of Short Brothers PLC.
4 Expenditure on arts and libraries in Northern Ireland is included with education and science.
5 Includes contribution to European Communities and expenditure associated with the general maintenance of government, such as tax collection and population registration.

Table 7a
General government expenditure1 in Great Britain and Northern Ireland, 1984–85 to 1988–89
£ million
As a percentage of Great Britain and Northern Ireland total
Great Britain Northern Ireland Total Great Britain Northern Ireland
1984–85 103,494.2 4,182.4 107,676.6 96.1 3.9
1985–86 109,051.4 4,444.1 113,495.5 96.1 3.9
1986–87 115,898.1 4,724.4 120,622.5 96.1 3.9
1987–88 122,951.2 4,921.2 127,872.3 96.2 3.8
1988–89 129,205.0 25,737.9 134,942.9 95.7 4.3

Table 7b
General government expenditure per head1 in Great Britain and Northern Ireland, 1984–85 to 1988–89
£ per head
Index (Great Britain and Northern Ireland = 100)
Great Britain Northern Ireland Total Great Britain Northern Ireland
1984–85 1,884.8 2,697.6 1,907.1 98.8 141.4
1985–86 1,980.6 2,852.8 2,004.6 98.8 142.3
1986–87 2,099.7 3,015.3 2,125.0 98.8 141.9
1987–88 2,221.1 3,124.3 2,246.1 98.9 139.1
1988–89 2,328.6 23,636.0 2,364.7 98.5 153.8
1 The figures in these tables differ from those for identifiable expenditure given in tables 1–6 because their coverage is wider; in particular some of the finance provided for nationalised industries is included.
2 Includes £390 million (£247 per head) for costs associated with the privatisation of Short Brothers plc.

Forward to