§ Mr. BeithTo ask the Secretary of State for Energy what statistical and demographic criteria, for each type of nuclear reactor, are used in Her Majesty's Nuclear Installations Inspectorate's assessment of the safety of sites for nuclear power stations; if he will publish a list showing for each existing nuclear power station(a) the relevant limiting criteria compared with (b) the actual population figures in each case; and if he will make a statement.
§ Mr. Michael SpicerI am advised by the HSE's Nuclear Installations Inspectorate that the current demographic criteria for assessing potential AGR sites were developed in the late 1960s. These and more restrictive criteria of a similar type are used as guidelines for controlling development in the vicinity of existing AGR and Magnox stations respectively. Once a site has been accepted for a nuclear station arrangements are made to ensure that residential and industrial developments are so controlled that the general characteristics of the site are preserved, and therefore local authorities consult the inspectorate with regard to any proposed development which might lead to an increase in population close to the site and on larger developments further from the site. Limiting criteria based upon population distribution are used only for guidance and the inspectorate would not necessarily insist on rigid adherence to them. Other unquantifiable factors are also taken into account.
The limiting criteria are in the form of cumulative weighted population out to various distances all around the site and in any 30 deg. sector. To assess a site against the criteria at a certain distance, the population for a given distance band is multiplied by the appropriate weighting factor and the values up to the distance being evaluated are added together. The weighting factors and limiting criteria for Magnox and AGR sites are:
359W
Distance (Km) Weighting factors Cumulative population Magnox Weighted criteria AGR Population all around site 0–2 32.0 45,000 290,000 2–3 15.0 69,000 520,000 3–5 7.7 120,000 870,000 5–8 4.0 180,000 1,300,000 Population in 30 deg. sector 0– 26.0 23,000 96,000
Distance (km) Weighting factors Cumulative population Magnox Weighted criteria AGR 2–3 12.0 37,000 170,000 3–5 5.6 48,000 290,000 5–8 2.8 56,000 430,000 Magnox reactors in concrete pressure vessels such as Oldbury and Wylfa would be allowed some relaxation of the general Magnox criteria if necessary.
The total populations around Magnox and AGR stations and the populations in the most restrictive 30 deg. sector are:
360W
Population around Magnox power stations (1981 Census data) Distance (km) Total 30° sector Hinkley Point 0 to 2 120 40 2 to 3 300 110 3 to 5 1,200 650 5 to 8 2,800 670 Berkeley 0 to 2 320 260 2 to 3 2,000 1,400 3 to 5 7,900 190 5 to 8 8,300 730 Trawsfynydd 0 to 2 320 60 2 to 3 290 20 3 to 5 1,500 640 5 to 8 5,400 4,000 Calder Hall 0 to 2 140 20 2 to 3 2,100 1,500 3 to 5 2,300 300 5 to 8 8,100 270 Sizewell 0 to 2 140 30 2 to 3 3,200 3,100 3 to 5 3,600 2,000 5 to 8 4,200 400 Bradwell 0 to 2 460 340 2 to 3 190 60 3 to 5 7,200 30 5 to 8 3,900 30 Dungeness 0 to 2 60 40 2 to 3 140 140 3 to 5 590 230 5 to 8 6,000 140 Oldbury 0 to 2 250 50 2 to 3 260 60 3 to 5 1,800 1,100 5 to 8 30,000 11,000 Wylfa 0 to 2 460 290 2 to 3 730 570 3 to 5 1,100 60 5 to 8 1,600 240 Hunterston 0 to 2 50 30 2 to 3 100 10 3 to 5 6,400 4,200 5 to 8 1,400 70
Distance (km) Total 30° sector Chapelcross 0 to 2 250 10 2 to 3 410 230 3 to 5 11,000 8,200 5 to 8 3,100 220
Population around AGR stations (1981 census data) Distance (Km) Total 30° sector Heysham 'A' 0 to 2 2,400 2,100 2 to 3 3,900 2,900 3 to 5 13,000 4,300 5 to 8 38,000 26,000 Heysham 'B' 0 to 2 2,200 2,100 2 to 3 3,700 3,100 3 to 5 13,000 11,000 5 to 8 40,000 24,000 Hartlepool 0 to 2 200 0 2 to 3 2,900 1,900 3 to 5 27,000 13,000 5 to 8 130,000 37,000 Torness 0 to 2 140 50 2 to 3 210 5 3 to 5 510 70 5 to 8 3,000 0 Population data for other AGRs at Hinkley Point, Dungeness and Hunterston are not given separately since control is exercised using the more restrictive Magnox criteria.