HC Deb 17 February 1955 vol 537 cc89-90W
Mr. Ian Harvey

asked the Secretary of State for War whether, in view of the representations concerning medical treatment made to him by the hon. Member for Harrow, East, he will re-examine the court of inquiry papers in the case of the late Gunner R. E. Hill in order to assure himself that the correct medical precautions and subsequent action were taken in this case.

Mr. Head

I have re-examined this case and have satisfied myself as requested by the hon. Member.

Mr. Ian Harvey

asked the Secretary of State for War what evidence exists that the late Gunner R. E. Hill did not report sick between 17th July, 1953, and 19th October, 1953.

Mr. Head

Sick Reports for the period contained no entries in respect of Gunner Hill and they are confirmed by oral evidence.

Mr. Ian Harvey

asked the Secretary of State for War why, in the case of the late Gunner R. E. Hill, the medical officer concerned persisted for so long in the view that his ailment was not serious and continued to prescribe an ineffectual remedy; and why he did not, at an earlier date than 19th October, 1953, consult specialist medical opinion.

Mr. Head

Before 19th October his condition, on examination, did not appear to be serious. During the previous months his symptoms resembled those of fibrositis and an X-ray early in February, 1953, showed no abnormality.