Lords Sitting of 16 August 1853

MINUTES.
PUBLIC BILLS.—2a Consolidated Fund Appropriation; Militia Tax; Land Tax Redemption Act Amendment; South Sea and other Annuities, Provision for Payment, &c.;
1752
Apprehension of Offenders Act Amendment; Betting Houses; Commons Inclosure (No. 3); Female Convicts; Loan Societies; Marriages, Holy Trinity Church, Hulme, Validity; Friendly Societies; Copyhold, &c. Commission Continuance; Metropolitan Sewers Acts Continuance; Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction.
Reported.—Land Tax Commissioners Names; Defacing the Coin; Linen, &c. Manufactures (Ireland); Militia Ballots Suspension and Militia Law Amendment; Smoke Nuisance Abatement (Metropolis); Stock in Trade Exemption; Customs Tariff Act; Customs Consolidation Act.
3a South Sea Company's Arrangement and Trusts; Merchant Shipping; Drainage of Lands (Ireland) Act Amendment; Universities (Scotland); Employment of Children in Factories; Public Works Acts Amendment (Ireland).

CASE OF VICAJEE MERJEE AND PESTONJEE MERJEE—EXPLANATION.
EARL GRANVILLErose to offer an explanation with reference to some observations which had fallen from him and another noble Earl (the Earl of Ellen-borough), with respect to a gentleman whose name had been mentioned in the course of the debate on the case of the Parsee Merchants. He (Earl Granville), upon the occasion to which he referred, had stated the fact that the Military Secretary at Hyderabad, Major Moore, had warned the petitioners whose case they had been discussing against lending money to the Nizam, and had told them that ruin would be the consequence of their pursuing such a course. The noble Earl opposite afterwards, in referring to that statement, had asked the House if Major Moore was not in the receipt of a pension from the Nizam, and had proceeded to make certain strictures upon the conduct of that officer. Now, he (Earl Granville), had since received a letter and documents from Major Moore, from which it appeared that the Court of Directors had in 1839 sanctioned the acceptance by Major Moore of the pension offered him by the Nizam, under very special circumstances.

SMOKE NUISANCE ABATEMENT (METROPOLIS) BILL.
The MARQUESS of LANSDOWNE, in moving that the House go into Committee on the Smoke Nuisance Abatement (Metropolis) Bill, observed that it was a measure of considerable importance, because it affected the comfort not only of their Lordships, but of every one in the metropolis, and every class of society. He believed that their Lordships were all aware, though they might not be aware of the whole ex-tent to which it had taken place, that they had been for years past subject to the gra-

1753
dual encroachment, not of an invisible enemy, but of an enemy who was perfectly obvious to any one, but whose approaches were so gradual that the whole extent could hardly be appreciated; and that at this moment, and for years past, they had been living, not under the canopy of heaven, but under one of their own creation. He need hardly tell their Lordships how injurious the smoke which now covered the metropolis was to works of art, and how much the evil called for some distinct interference of the Legislature, provided their legislation could be carried out without undue interference with the rights of parties. The experiments of the last seven years had abundantly proved that their Lordships could with perfect safety, without imposing any burdens upon individuals beyond some amount of attention and trouble, require the extinction and consumption of all smoke generated by manufacturing establishments. It was proposed by this Bill, that after the 1st of August next year all furnaces should be compelled to consume their own smoke, with the exception of glass works and potteries, throughout the metropolitan districts, and the Bill included the steam-boats on the river. There was an impression that this was a sort of dilettante measure, only sought for the benefit of the rich, and the preservation of works of art. He should be the last to say that works of art should not be protected, and that it was a wise policy to amass in the metropolis collections of the most valuable description. He thought that object alone was deserving the protecting hand of their Lordships. But so far from its being only for the interest of the richer classes, only affecting the feelings of amateurs and preservation of works of art—it affected every class of the community and the general cleanliness of the metropolis, for there was no housekeeper who was not able to vouch for the increased difficulty in maintaining the commonest cleanliness in consequence of the nuisance which this Bill would abate. The smoke so affected the clothing of the working classes that it was computed every mechanic paid at least five times the amount of the original cost of his shirt for the number of washings rendered necessary. Therefore, in proposing this Bill, he was assuming the functions of the Chancellor of the Exchequer, as it would make a considerable reduction of a duty levied upon the whole community not the less rigorously because they were hardly aware of it. The Bill, while affording that relief did so with singular care—
1754
he might also say more care than was necessary for the interests of the parties upon whom it would operate, because although six months was first proposed to be allowed for every manufacturer to provide himself with this machinery, that period had been extended to the 1st of August next. The provisions of the Bill were the same as had been adopted in various local Acts of Parliament. There were five or six places, including a part of the metropolis, White-chapel, in which provisions for this purpose were enforced; and in many instances in which persons had been compelled to adopt the new machinery they had found themselves benefited in point of economy by the change. He thought it unnecessary to say more upon a matter so obviously for the public advantage.
House in Committee.
Bill reported without Amendment.
Loan REDESDALEcongratulated the House and the country upon the introduction of this Bill, and expressed his obligations to the Government for having undertaken to pass so necessary a measure. He had himself carried two Bills for the same purpose through their Lordships' House; but not receiving the support of the Government, it had proved impossible to carry them through the other House of Parliament. If this Bill did not do all he desired, it was still a great improvement. He regretted that the operation of the Bill was postponed, as it created unnecessary delay; but since that was an agreement come to for the withdrawal of certain opposition, he should not interfere with it. He regretted also that glass works and potteries were excepted. A Bill had passed that very year for the improvement of Newcastle-on-Tyne, where more glass was made than in any other place in England, and no such exemption had been required in that instance. He considered that a great blot upon the measure; but he should not propose any alteration. He should, however, move amendments to make the words of enacting clause the same as the preamble, with respect to steam vessels between London-bridge and Richmond-bridge, and to modify the third clause, which provided that no penalty should attach where only coke or other fuel, not emitting smoke, was used. With respect to that proviso it would enable parties to evade the proviso it would enable parties to evade the operation of the Act; and it was only necessary to observe a railway train to see that coke put on rudely did emit smoke; and he, therefore, should propose to limit the exemption to cases in which no smoke was caused.

1755
He thought no one could object to those amendments; but if they endangered the passing of the Bill, he trusted the Government would at once give them up.
The MARQUESS of LANSDOWNEapproved of the amendments, and had no objection to their introduction, upon the understanding that, if objected to elsewhere, they should be given up. He reminded the noble Lord that, with respect to glass works and potteries, the Bill would apply to those parts of the works which created the most noxious smoke.
Amendments made; and Bill to be read 3a on Thursday next.
House adjourned to Thursday next.