HC Deb 27 February 1922 vol 151 cc49-50
96. Captain DIXON

asked the Minister of Agriculture whether he is aware that the detention of Irish store cattle is causing great loss to farmers; and whether he will now withdraw the Detention Order?

Sir A. BOSCAWEN

Yes, Sir, I am aware that some loss is unfortunately being incurred by farmers in consequence of the detention of Irish store cattle, but the situation with regard to foot-and-mouth disease has not yet improved sufficiently to justify me in withdrawing the Order.

Captain DIXON

Is it not the fact that there has been absolutely no disease of any kind in Ireland?

Sir A. BOSCAWEN

I have said before that we have not been able to trace the actual existence of disease in Ireland, but apart from that the movements of Irish store cattle from market to market is, in my opinion, a very fruitful way of spreading disease, and we do not see our way at the present time to remove the Order.

Lieut.-Colonel MURRAY

Why not remove the embargo on Canadian cattle?

Sir F. BANBURY

Is it not the fact that Irish store cattle, when in England, are found to have disease, and that when in Ireland apparently they do not have it?