HC Deb 01 November 1920 vol 134 cc46-7
52. Mr. WALLACE

asked the Prime Minister whether the Government have yet come to a decision regarding the raising of the status of the Secretary for Scotland to that of Secretary of State for Scotland?

The PRIME MINISTER

The Government are of the opinion that the change suggested in this question ought to be made, but, as the House knows, they are also of the opinion that the salaries attached to some of the other Cabinet offices are inadequate. We propose, therefore, to appoint immediately a Select Committee of this House to examine into the question.

Mr. WALLACE

Does not the right hon. Gentleman think the case of the Secretary for Scotland comes under a special category, having regard to the fact that from his own office he has to discharge the functions of at least four Ministers, and the salary attached to his office is less than half that of an English Secretary of State?

The PRIME MINISTER

I recognise fully the case put by my hon. Friend. There is a special case as far as Scotland is concerned.

Mr. HOGGE

Do I understand that the Select Committee is to investigate the salaries of all Ministers?

The PRIME MINISTER

No, only certain offices which are low paid, but which are offices of very great responsibility.

Mr. HOGGE

When will the Committee be set up?

The PRIME MINISTER

Immediately.

Mr. WALLACE

Does not the right hon. Gentleman consider there is a special case for a special Bill for the Secretary for Scotland?

Sir F. BANBURY

Will the right hon. Gentleman give an undertaking to wait until the finances of the country are in a sounder position before increasing salaries?

Sir H. CRAIK

Is it not the case that when the Bill for increasing the status and salaries of the Secretary for Scotland was before the House it was opposed by the hon. Member who puts the question?

Mr. WALLACE

Yes, on the ground that other Ministers were included.